milo
Jack L. Jones
Re: England's last world cup game for 12 years!!!!!
Exaggerated for comic effect but he makes some good points
Exaggerated for comic effect but he makes some good points
A lot of people focus on the number of foreigners in our league and pinpoint that as the reason for a lack for international success.
That IMO may be a factor but there are many factors and let's face it - foreign players are a big factor in most countries; England IMO is quite unique to many of the other countries...
The British Empire - England's cricket team benefits more than it's footie team does predominately because the population with Caribbean and South Asian heritage are big-time on the sport, much more so than they are at footie. Spain and Portugal have an advantage here... On a tangent, can we take advantage of immigration in the future with people from footie nations such as Poland, Romania, Bulgaria, etc (much like it seems Germany, Switzerland, Netherlands, France, etc)?
Grassroots Football - The ethos in the past has been to 'get it out!' rather than emphasis on technical footie. This is a personal observation playing in London based 'English' leagues and other 'Mediterranean' leagues. Taking on players was encouraged in the latter whereas you'd get big Les shouting at you for keeping the ball (admittedly my experiences were 15-20 odd years ago so I'm sure it's changed now).
Good Loser Another thing we're particularly good at. It's all about taking part - this philosophy is bred from a young age. I think this does have it's merits for young children but it seems to filter through into adulthood too. It is actually commendable to be a good loser but it may take away the bite of being successful.
DO YOU SPEAK ENGLISH!?!?! Why are these players not getting international experience??? We know the EPL is fantastic but learn from different cultures and leagues! I cannot think of another big footie nation's players having less air-miles!! German, Spanish, Italian, Brazilian, Argentinian, Portuguese, France, Belgian... They all travel!!! Is it because of the language? Do our players struggle with their own that they are afraid to learn another???
Other Sports Perhaps footie isn't as big as we think it is? We don't have the biggest population and perhaps other sports get equal amount of interest AND/OR do not follow the above issues?
There may also be cultural elements (education, class, family, etc) but as mentioned - I do think we have an unrealistic expectation - particularly due to the focus and money of the EPL...
Just back from holiday and knackered - apologies for the mumbling...
I think a lot of those kids will opt to play for their country of birth/parents place of birth. I very much see us being like France in this respect with young kids from eastern European households training up to U21 level before opting to play for someone else.
I think it will depend on where they think that will get the most chances. Most of the French players opting for Algeria would not get as many caps for France.
The problem with England comes down to nobody trying to actually fix anything
How the **** does Hodgson still have his job? what would it take to classify him as a failure?
What the **** was Gerrard, Lampard & Rooney doing on the pitch today? a thank you gesture? for ****ing what, 2 goals between the 3 of them in World Cups combined? Hodgson had to be taking the ****, no one over 25 should have been on that pitch today.
So if the manager isn't going to change, the FA isn't going to change, the picking of fringe players from sky 4 clubs isn't going to change, the public's attention span of a fly that allows them to be distracted by **** like "Spurs players skip England games" isn't going to change, then the next 50 years is likely to be the same as the previous = **** all
A record of one semi-final overseas in 64 years since points to the absence of any coherent remedial measures. The same flaws are there, chiefly the simple failure to produce high-quality, tactically state-of-the-art players, the result of a combination of societal neglect – we play too little; we have too little space to play – and an enduringly inadequate coaching culture, backed higher up by a failure to nurture and show patience with what talent does emerge.
You're saying that Hodgson should lose his job, but at the same time you complain about the public's attention span and how easily distracted they are. I don't understand that. For me the manager issue is just as much of a distraction issue and one that takes up the focus whereas the real problem remains unchecked.
Although of course one of the real attempts of doing something that could help included the proposal of B teams for the big PL teams and was thus heavily objected to.
I disagree Raziel, the problem is that we have idiots trying to fix it
a general English problem sadly
Somewhere someone did claim that perhaps winning the World Cup in '66 hurt English football long term and that the idea that you just had to return to what was done then and that nothing was wrong with the fundamentals of English football was instilled as an idea and since lived by.
Agree with most of that - except the lack of space.
For a kick about that is fine, we used to play in the road, but the selling off of playing fields certainly won't have helped with coaching young kidsAgree with most of that - except the lack of space.
There's not much space in a favela, Indian cricketers learn in no space at all - if you want to play you'll find space. In dropping my wife off at work (teacher in a sink estate) we drive past a lot of spaces that could easily be used for a kick about. Yet even during a World Cup I've seen kids kicking a ball around once.
Compare that to when I was at junior school. I'd be in at 8 so I could have half an hour of football on our concrete courtyard. Morning and afternoon break I'd be out there playing a 15 min match and every lunch the same.
Now they're just filling their faces with Greggs and getting each other pregnant.
If the kids aren't having a kick about then there's nobody to coach.For a kick about that is fine, we used to play in the road, but the selling off of playing fields certainly won't have helped with coaching young kids
Regardless of the fact that Hodgson is not the cause, he is part of the problem, and failure at that level cannot be accepted without some consequence. This is the same issue of Gerrard/Lampard/Terry/etc. failing to deliver time and time again and somehow still playing, still be selected.
If someone can be bothered to search for it, I'm sure I wrote on this board when Hodgson was selected that England would qualify boringly and go out early of a major tournament with a whimper under Hodgson, amazingly predictable ..
It's a point I made after the Uruguay game but it was lifted from the Numbers Game
Sent from my Nexus 5 using Fapatalk
Agree with most of that - except the lack of space.
There's not much space in a favela, Indian cricketers learn in no space at all - if you want to play you'll find space. In dropping my wife off at work (teacher in a sink estate) we drive past a lot of spaces that could easily be used for a kick about. Yet even during a World Cup I've seen kids kicking a ball around once.
Compare that to when I was at junior school. I'd be in at 8 so I could have half an hour of football on our concrete courtyard. Morning and afternoon break I'd be out there playing a 15 min match and every lunch the same.
Now they're just filling their faces with Greggs and getting each other pregnant.
the problem is that we have idiots trying to fix it
TVs Greg Dyke said:It's a shame Harry didn't come last week, he probably would have helped.
Agree with most of that - except the lack of space.
There's not much space in a favela, Indian cricketers learn in no space at all - if you want to play you'll find space. In dropping my wife off at work (teacher in a sink estate) we drive past a lot of spaces that could easily be used for a kick about. Yet even during a World Cup I've seen kids kicking a ball around once.
Compare that to when I was at junior school. I'd be in at 8 so I could have half an hour of football on our concrete courtyard. Morning and afternoon break I'd be out there playing a 15 min match and every lunch the same.
Now they're just filling their faces with Greggs and getting each other pregnant.
For a kick about that is fine, we used to play in the road, but the selling off of playing fields certainly won't have helped with coaching young kids