Gazza Dazzla
Chris Perry
In my opinion he won't work. For teams that want a target man to hold the the ball up then great. For teams the use pace and movement he'll struggle to be effective.
Can you imagine Carroll keeping up with Bale or Lennon to get on the end of their crosses?
If he was mobile with pace then yes I could see him working, but he's neither of those.
He'd be back up to Ade and a pretty good plan B (as Crouch should have been), but I wouldn't want to pay much more than 10m for him and Liverpool wouldn't let him come to us for anything less than a ridiculous fee.