I'm not sure it's head scratching, Poch is very hard to have a legitimate conversation about
Facts re Poch
- Best manager of our modern era (easy give)
- United the fans/club in a way very few have
- Has a very good relationship still with club & Levy
Seems such an easy fit, so what's the argument against Poch?
- The end of his era was bad (this is often seen in a much better light due to revisionist history) but alongside that CL run was 1 away win in 11 months, 25 points from 24 games, 18 losses in a calendar year
- He was poor with subs
- He didn't want to work with a DoF (his famous, I'm just a coach rant), and seeming not a good judge of players to buy
- He fudged up on youth players (something he's normally given credit for), his refusal to let young players out on loan was a poor strategy
- In the end, the senior players wanted out, Eriksen & Toby examples
- He was poor with managing players with injuries, players that needed cotton wool (Dembele & Lamela)
- Almost man, his teams didn't take the last step
- Given better players in PSG neither the results or the football was elite
Lots of caveats
- Wembley move at hight of our rise
- Lack of money to refresh at the point most needed
- Bad recruitment (partly on him, see above re DoF)
I can see why the club is thinking about it