• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Yang Min-Hyeok

I guess what is done is done.

However, does this mean that if a PL club buys an EU national at 17/18 and loans them back to a European club, then they will never get a homegrown status? Thinking about Vuskovic who would now need to stay under the FA's jurisdiction of PL and EFL moving forward.

So you could never get a Saliba situation again?
UK law no longer recognises an EU citizen as being any different from any other non-UK citizen in terms of right to work in the UK.

So right to work in the UK is the key element a foreign player must have in place to be signed from 18 (a PL club can not register a foreign player before their 18th birthday) and loaned out to a club outside the English FA'S jurisdiction.

As EU citizens no longer have an automatic right to work in the UK the only way you'd achieve this is to have a UK work permit approved and in place prior to the loan abroad, which under the established criteria for work permits to be approved for foreign footballers need to be able to demonstrate the foreign worker is going to add to the English game which was
usually demonstrated by having so many senior or international appearances.

However the PL worked with the home office to make changes to the work permit criteria for footballers to make it easier to get one (in anticipation of English clubs losing access to recruiting the best European talent)...and Football London appear to suggest Vuskovic could have qualified for a UK permit under the new rules from his 18th birthday so he could still end up being "home grown" if that's the case...
 
UK law no longer recognises an EU citizen as being any different from any other non-UK citizen in terms of right to work in the UK.

So right to work in the UK is the key element a foreign player must have in place to be signed from 18 (a PL club can not register a foreign player before their 18th birthday) and loaned out to a club outside the English FA'S jurisdiction.

As EU citizens no longer have an automatic right to work in the UK the only way you'd achieve this is to have a UK work permit approved and in place prior to the loan abroad, which under the established criteria for work permits to be approved for foreign footballers need to be able to demonstrate the foreign worker is going to add to the English game which was
usually demonstrated by having so many senior or international appearances.

However the PL worked with the home office to make changes to the work permit criteria for footballers to make it easier to get one (in anticipation of English clubs losing access to recruiting the best European talent)...and Football London appear to suggest Vuskovic could have qualified for a UK permit under the new rules from his 18th birthday so he could still end up being "home grown" if that's the case...

Yes, but if he spends time between 18 and 21 playing on loan in Europe, can he still get club trained status? Ditto Yang.

That is what is unclear to me. I guess it's different with Devine as he'll still have enough tenure to be club trained even if he spend time abroad.
 
Yes, but if he spends time between 18 and 21 playing on loan in Europe, can he still get club trained status? Ditto Yang.

That is what is unclear to me. I guess it's different with Devine as he'll still have enough tenure to be club trained even if he spend time abroad.
Don’t think it’s been tested yet to know
 
Yes, but if he spends time between 18 and 21 playing on loan in Europe, can he still get club trained status? Ditto Yang.

That is what is unclear to me. I guess it's different with Devine as he'll still have enough tenure to be club trained even if he spend time abroad.
Club trained is a UEFA rule and is pretty much the same as the PL "home grown" rule but there doesn't appear to be any wording around loans so it's unclear in terms of that particular situation which would impact his registration for us in UEFA competitions...
 
So I wonder if he is training today and we will see an update from the spurs admin. Would be good for all spurs fans and the South Korean contingency to show them that he has finally started with us.
 
I’d settle for him hitting the ground running, like Kulusevski who had 2 goals plus 3 assists in his first 6 PL games after he joined us 3 Januarys ago.
I just want someone who can actually run at their defender with the ball under control at thier feet 😅 and not fudging pass the ball backwards 90% of the time. I want someone the rest of the team have confidence in playing into him.

Hopefully Hyeok can be something towards that.
 
I just want someone who can actually run at their defender with the ball under control at thier feet 😅 and not fudging pass the ball backwards 90% of the time. I want someone the rest of the team have confidence in playing into him.

Hopefully Hyeok can be something towards that.

Good point and i do agree, that is why when i saw Oderbert he looked that type of player would could do that well. Pity he got injured hope he gets fit soon.
 
Even if his hamstrings come through training sessions AND he gets onto the pitch, some Villa (etc) thug will break his ankle or stamp on his achilles in his first match and put him out for weeks. It's the Spurs way.
 
Good point and i do agree, that is why when i saw Oderbert he looked that type of player would could do that well. Pity he got injured hope he gets fit soon.
Even though not as far developed Mikey Moore too.

Hopefully Yang will settle in quickly. Think we should be careful with our expectations on him, but given our injury situation he perhaps get some minutes fairly quickly.
 
Even though not as far developed Mikey Moore too.

Hopefully Yang will settle in quickly. Think we should be careful with our expectations on him, but given our injury situation he perhaps get some minutes fairly quickly.

Agree, having worked with young players during my time you can never really know just how they will work out/push on. Some fall by the wayside it needs a lot of patience and commitment from both player and coaches. Fans will always get carried away at times [ only to be expected with young talent] but for everyone that excels there are many more [sadly] that do not.
 
Last edited:
I assume it hasn’t formally gone through yet. Assume today is the 1st day you submit paper work to the FA for a transfer in this window, I’d imagine you need to get something from the FA for the work permit as well.
 
Back