Articles like that can be countered by what he was showing on the pitch
I saw him boss games for Lyon against better sides … that’s the ability question ticked
He also had to come back form being dumped as a youth player. That’s testament to a mind set
It’s impossible for anyone to know things about mind set and dare I say when you question a player and they don’t speak the same language it’s possible things don’t land as they might.
I’ve seen articles also talking about Demebele of a simailr ilk. It’s speculation that can be flipped both ways
100%It was exactly the type of signing Levy is criticised for never making.
The comparison with Dembele is interesting. He'd struggled a lot under AVB and Timmeh, didn't really have a best position, and was a bit of a lost end. Poch them took him out of the team (for Mason and Bentaleb), and used him sparingly as a RAM sub. But then him mentally, and the coaching he was receiving, finally really clicked, and he went on to have 3 or 4 absolutely imperious years.
It kind of makes you think what might of happened if Ndombele had kept the manager who bought him. If he had a pat on the back rather than a succession of kick up the arse coaches. If Poch would have been a Venables/Walter Smith to his Gascoigne. Sliding doors.
I've never criticised Levy for this signing and never will. Like @Bedfordspurs has said it hasn't worked but not due to a lack of talent. He's exactly the type of player we should have gone for, that it didn't work was unforeseeable. So I think it would be really unfair to criticise the board for him not working out.It was exactly the type of signing Levy is criticised for never making.
Way over the top imo, we big up players so much on here when they do something special but this is ridiculous. He is no where near one of the most technically gifted players ever, he is technically gifted don’t get me wrong but i bet if you tried, you could find hundreds of players with highlights doing things he done. Vastly overrated and isn’t fit to lace Moussa’s boots, he will always be looked at as a Temu version of Dembele.One of the most technically gifted players ever.
One of the mentally weakest would appear. Could be another who is a victim of the era. As an old skool #10 with no defensive responsibility he'd be lethal.
Not sure how you can know that for a fact
We don’t know what is going on between someone’s ears and IMO it’s dangerous to assume things like that
But what we do know is his application on the pitch wasn’t good enough for a player earning that much money.
Im not defending himThe money is irrelevant, I expect commitment from all our players even if they've only getting a cup of tea and a bun. We have 60,000 people at every home game who would pay to play and run through a brick wall for the privilege. The scout team must take the blame if they recommend him.
With everything factored in....he must be our worst signing ever.
I think that came across in the Amazon documentaryHe looked depressed from the minute he walked through the door looking back, at the time i tried to look past it but you look at those early interviews and the way he carried himself knowing how his time here played out and it seems quite obvious
Gilberto says hi!With everything factored in....he must be our worst signing ever.
20 years apart, and Gilberto looked like someone who had never played football!wasn't he like 2.5m?
and Ndomble about 60m?
20 years apart, and Gilberto looked like someone who had never played football!
Apart from that scam bloke Souness signed, Gilberto is probably one of the worst player ever to play in the premier league.