Fine win by the U21s tonight - Falque with another brace.
Will still never make it at the top level
<cue abuse>
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Iago_Falqué
He is 23 yo.
It is not the end but as Churchill said it could be the end of the beginning or even the opposite.
There's some real quality players in that lot.
Let's hope Spurs can pick-up where we left-off last season and win the U21 League Championship again.
why?
will we play some of them in the first team? maybe we will but if they do not turn into the best player in the league over night and have a few quiet games, you know in the way we used to allow young players to do. Well if they do that they will probably just end up being sold to Cardiff
why?
will we play some of them in the first team? maybe we will but if they do not turn into the best player in the league over night and have a few quiet games, you know in the way we used to allow young players to do. Well if they do that they will probably just end up being sold to Cardiff
Yes.
Spurs Academy Players who tasted first team action in 2012-13:
Steven Caulker
Jake Livermore
Tom Carroll
Andros Townsend
Adam Smith
Ryan Mason
Jon Obika
Harry Kane
...in addition, Shaquile Coulthirst, Dean Parrett, Jordan Archer and Kevin Stewart gained first team squad experience without any playing time.
jgl:
Carroll turned 21 this summer. Iirc we signed Carrick when he was 23. I think you should give Carroll, and Spurs/AVB some time before you make your mind up on what's happening.
Not sure how many 20 year old central midfielders of any nationality establish themselves at top clubs in the PL these days. I can't think of many examples off the top of my head, I challenge you to come up with some examples of players with Carroll's physique that's established themselves at that age.
Townsend turned 22 this summer. Yes there are younger wingers that establish themselves, it's an easier position to break into for younger players for sure. But that's around the same age that Ashley Young was sold to Aston Villa. A bit premature to be demanding that he should be given regular playing time for Spurs in my eyes.
You see i kind of agree with what your saying, but also im right and your wrong, we will not sadly give them the chance. They are going the way of caulker, i like this thread the best on this website but im not sure if the is much point in it sometimes.
If AVB prioritizes giving youth a chance over playing his strongest team, how long before he's out of a job?
For the first team and the head coach it's pretty simple: Win. If/when any of our youth players are good enough they'll get a chance, but we're not yet at that stage where we can carry inferior players in the team. Man Utd under Fergie have done it, but the other 9-10 players were usually pretty exceptional and anyone coming from the academy have to show the right attitude and work their asses off.
I think the club is doing pretty well in producing players that go on to have a career as professional footballers. To become a "Champions League quality" player you have to either be pretty special or cover your flaws through hard work.
Or maybe like a few other ex barcelona players he has taken his time to grow into the physical side of the game and put all aspects of his game together. Arteta was another like that.
Im not saying he will make it but i find it odd how some think if a player has not made the first team of a club by 20/21 then he will nevver make it.
Michu was on his way out of football a couple of years ago, studying at university and thinking of giving the game up before giving it another chance, he turned out ok and managed to score a few in the top league in both spain and england.
Im not saying Falque will do this, but maybe we are looking at players with attributes that we want and then are looking at coaching them to play in a distinct style(runnning all the way through the club) and then make the first team and be of useful purpose to the team.
This sort of attitude of hey he is not a star by 21 get rid i find a bit odd but sums up the youth of today who i feel do not want to work at things and see improvement.
You have a tendency to either not read what I print or deliberately misunderstand it.
My first line is "It is NOT the end" but 23 is pushing it
I certainly do not write off players who are not world beaters in their early twenties. Ian Wright was playing on Blackheath in his twenties. The Morison Welsh international was a navvy in his twenties and there are other examples.
I have not given up on Obika, even.
But you can look at some players and tell whether they will ever be good enough. I have seen Falque a couple of times and he was OK. Just OK.
I 99% agree with you but just to take Kane as an example: I thought he warranted a place on the bench last term on the strength of his successful Millwall loan. He did well against Monaco but probably won't play today and probably will be sent on loan again this season.
ITK says AVB turned down Shaw so would he have turned down Bale, too?
“There were a lot of pleasing things, the more experienced players were great for us while the likes of Giancarlo, Ruben, Alex McQueen and Grant Ward have all come onto the scene this season and they are trying their best to step up and live up to the standards that were set last season