We have to agree to disagree on that one. Sure, those kind of players aren't seen much anymore, but that's more down to being exceptional examples rather than being outdated as a role, in my opinion. And even if the level of "pamperedness" in football today probably is on another level than only 20 years ago, they're still mostly kids earning more money that they can spend, now as well as then. Which brings us down to "winning mentality" again. If you come from a normal background being talented in one thing, earning 100K+/w playing/training what you love for a couple of hours a day, haven't you reached the goal of 99% of any human being? I think this was the beginning of the end of the reigns of ManU and Arsenal, a sudden influx of players having reached their goal just by being there. Winning something was just a bonus. Loosely speaking, of course - again noone likes to lose. It's completely different in individual sports, where winning mentality is everything and losing out meaning not getting paid (sponsorship aside, but then again you have to show at least great potential to get anything bigger than Grandma's Garments).
Anyway, Kane is too much of a good guy for my choice, which is by no means the definitive answer I must add. I am also a fan of a (defensive) midfielder as captain, a keeper as we have certainly doesn't do it for me as his movement is so restricted. If you like lead-by-example, Kane is obviously a good choice. But I'd rather have a player more involved, and with the ability to read and hopefully influence the dynamics of the game more.
The part in bold is essentially why i don't think the type captain that you are championing would work in the football of today - the players won't respond to the stick when they are already at a level that brings them everything they ever wanted, not in my opinion anyway. I think you need an entirely different approach to motivating top tier players (generally speaking) now because of the huge change in lifestyle of late teen to early 30s men these past 10 years or so - i mean can you imagine what Roy Keane would make of Lingard and Rashford and how they carry on via social media? it'd be carnage, he'd tear them to pieces - it just wouldn't work, times have changed
Last edited: