Some comments from reddit... Who knows maybe his chairman was the Italian Levy!
legohoxb77
People overrate his later contributions. Everyone knew De Ligt was an amazing player and prospect and many teams were in for him. Nothing special there. Chiesa was also a pretty well known commodity.
Ramsey was a failure. Rabiot has been inconsistent - at times world class at times not. McKennie was a good buy but the jury is still out. He had a strong first season but so too did bentancur. We will see. Morata is the same Morata as he was the last 5 years.
In terms of results on the pitch, he made 2 rather poor managerial hires with Sarri and Pirlo, and the team got worse each progressive year with him at the helm. It's not all his fault, but you can't be a director and not accept responsibility.
It has been frustrating that he hasn't solved our midfield issues for 3 years.
BrotherKing
Good a buying, Bad at selling.
Thats the short story imo
spyrgy
One of the best at finding talent, but bad at shifting dead weight and fixing holes in the team. We've got a great young base of players but also our wage bill is massive and we have a lot of players we need to get rid of. He did manage to sign Ronaldo and De Ligt, so he has a track record of closing big deals too.
HardSkism
I had a ton of hope for Fabio when Marotta left. In fact I felt he made Marotta look good...but when he was left on his own, I felt he wasnt worth the hype. I say this for a few reasons:
Was unable to build a proper midfield that suited three different coaches (You could argue Allegri last year doesnt count, but it wasnt what it was in his previous years)
Was unable to move dead weight (see rugani, de sciglio, costa, khedira) for multiple seasons
Full backs were a problem and it wasn't addressed as well as it could've been
Great at finding talent no doubt, but he lacked that magic when building a balanced team. If he simply works in the capacity to find the talent that addresses the needs of the club, he will be very good
Sent from my SM-T865 using
glory-glory.co.uk mobile app