• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

ENIC

braineclipse said:
I agree he's not a top level player/striker.

Top level strikers move for way more than Richarlison unless there are contract issues or other issues going on.

We probably did overpay a bit, but not by a massive amount imo. That's close to the going rate for a good, not top level high level proven striker. Which kind of returns to a repeating point here. Come on Levy back the manager, just pay what it takes to get the player the manager wants and needs.
Click to expand...
I sometimes find it difficult to figure out if we overpaid for him. Gut feel says yes we did by about £15 million.

But then I think how much would a striker at his peak with not contract issues that would get you 20 goals a season cost? £125-150m? Therefore what about one that would get you 15 goals a season?

I think Richi is probably a 12-15 goals a season striker so we weren’t too far off. Having said that I wouldn’t have paid more than £45 for him lol
 
RunTMC said:
I sometimes find it difficult to figure out if we overpaid for him. Gut feel says yes we did by about £15 million.

But then I think how much would a striker at his peak with not contract issues that would get you 20 goals a season cost? £125-150m? Therefore what about one that would get you 15 goals a season?

I think Richi is probably a 12-15 goals a season striker so we weren’t too far off. Having said that I wouldn’t have paid more than £45 for him lol
Click to expand...
A fit richy is a 1 in 2 striker
He doesn’t ever mean he to stay fit
That’s the killer now
He is physically unreliable
Then add in his lack of versatility as a type of striker and you have some issues
But the fee was the fee needed for them to sell him
 
Bedfordspurs said:
A fit richy is a 1 in 2 striker
He doesn’t ever mean he to stay fit
That’s the killer now
He is physically unreliable
Then add in his lack of versatility as a type of striker and you have some issues
But the fee was the fee needed for them to sell him
Click to expand...

He was 1 in 2 for an about a 15 game stretch one season. He’s not a 1 in 2 striker over the length of his career.
 
We probably paid a little too much for Richi BUT realistically you can't even cast judgement on the price, his worth, his ability as the whole thing has been blighted and disrupted by injuries.

Of course, an assessment of his capability to stay fit should be made before signing on the dotted line (id assume it was?) and he did have that run of games (around when he scored a great goal at Goodison) where he showed he could really be effective and a player.

But the fitness issues overrides everything including, imo, the need to move him on. It not just curtails his desire to show the player he is BUT hinders any forward planning a manager is required to do week to week.
 
ricky2tricky4city said:
We probably paid a little too much for Richi BUT realistically you can't even cast judgement on the price, his worth, his ability as the whole thing has been blighted and disrupted by injuries.

Of course, an assessment of his capability to stay fit should be made before signing on the dotted line (id assume it was?) and he did have that run of games (around when he scored a great goal at Goodison) where he showed he could really be effective and a player.

But the fitness issues overrides everything including, imo, the need to move him on. It not just curtails his desire to show the player he is BUT hinders any forward planning a manager is required to do week to week.
Click to expand...
Erm no, I can asses his abilities because I watched this guy for both Everton and Watford. This is what I mean, why do I need to wait for him to come to Spurs to form an opinion of him when I already have one borne out of at least 30+ 90m games. I was paying attention to him because at the earlier stage of his career I thought he had some potential, turns out not to be the case.

Again this one where people speak of injuries. His injury record has kept him in better stead than if he had actually been for for significant periods because believe me if he had played 90+ games over the last 3 years your opinion of him would be very different.
 
He had that purple patch at the end of the season before we bought him, when his goals basically kept Everton up, but outside of that ...
Seems a likeable guy, but I always doubted his quality and I nearly spat my tea when I saw what we paid for him. He's never been a finisher.
 
Bishop said:
Again this one where people speak of injuries. His injury record has kept him in better stead than if he had actually been for for significant periods because believe me if he had played 90+ games over the last 3 years your opinion of him would be very different.
Click to expand...
Erm no, (sorry to plagiarise:))...he hasn't played 90+ games so I wouldn't be able to form that opinion. Thanks for telling me what opinion I would form on something that hasn't even happened :)

He definitely looked to be a talent at Watford. Then went to a brick club.
So I'd give any player a bit of time to prove themselves at another club given their situation changes.

As I said, the thing he has most proven is he is injury prone...that's enough to move him on.
 
ricky2tricky4city said:
Erm no, (sorry to plagiarise:))...he hasn't played 90+ games so I wouldn't be able to form that opinion. Thanks for telling me what opinion I would form on something that hasn't even happened :)

He definitely looked to be a talent at Watford. Then went to a brick club.
So I'd give any player a bit of time to prove themselves at another club given their situation changes.

As I said, the thing he has most proven is he is injury prone...that's enough to move him on.
Click to expand...
The injuries are exactly why to sell him
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back