Do you have any numbers on how many people were killed from non-violent arrests and call-outs? I genuinely don't know, but I'd be surprised if it's a significant number.
What's the plan when what would have started non-violent becomes violent and there's no police there? Is the cost to the lives of social workers worth the saving? Again, don't know the answer but it's an obvious problem.
Finally, (sorry to bombard with so many questions but you're the first person capable of forming a sentence I've heard support this stuff) why have BLM taken this issue up? Seems a little out of scope to me. After all, the data available in the US are fairly clear that once an arrest becomes violent, black men (I say men because it almost always is) are less likely to be shot than white men. Shouldn't this be an issue taken up by that prick with the message on the back of the Cesna?
Scara, apologies for the delay, I made a quite fabulous post with links and everything, then lost it, and now can't be bothered to spend more time trying to recreate it (did I mention I have a new girlfriend?). In short....
I don't have the numbers, did do a bit of research but from what I can gather part of the problem is the voluntary nature of providing stats in these areas via officers and agencies. Also part of my problem is I don't like numbers and get bored easily.
Second question, in short is there any way of assessing this without seeing the community-led enforcement model in practice alongside the Police? In the case of homelessness, mental health and addiction, having groups and individuals with the correct training and experience will surely reduce violent interactions, which is part of the 'plan' for defunding the police. Just on the whole 'defund the police' moniker, this article explains the actual concept with a bit more clarity
https://www.brookings.edu/blog/fixg...efund-the-police-mean-and-does-it-have-merit/
When we talk about defunding the police in the US, it is a very different animal to the UK. Police budgets over there are huge, the NYPD budget is 10x that of London I think? It's simply allocating some funds into designated social/community areas of expertise. Working example is decriminalising drug use in Portugal and making addiction and the surrounding implications a health-centred issue as opposed to a police issue.
Last question, I think it's important to state that whilst BLM have become the megaphone for the 'defund the police' movement in 2020, this isn't a race issue but more a societal issue, specifically based around class in my opinion (when you look at stats of who, where and why civilians are on the receiving end of police brutality).
Also regarding data, are black men only less likely to be shot purely by numbers? In terms of per capita or per x, are they not more likely to be shot? Again, had some lovely graphs and other such things I don't understand to present but hey ho.
Can I go back to having sex now?