@Grays_1890 , even excluding the 'corporate funding' aspect behind many such channels, it will be supremely interesting to see how these 'Fan TV' ventures all end up, to be honest. Instinctively, the idea of fans making money off of the anger and disappointment of other fans after games seems to run contrary to everything being a fan is about, and everything being part of a group of people all united by their passion is about more broadly. If the stuff about AFTV *hiring* those 'bludfam' chancers to play up on screen for Youtube money is true, then that's even worse from the perspective of going against what being a fan is supposed to be. If you're disappointed with the result and/or the club as a whole, you want to be able to share that with your fellow fans, or at least know that they're suffering that way too - but then some guy who ostensibly supports your club starts raking in tons of Youtube/merchandising money by getting similarly self-interested people to play characters on screen while being seemingly blase about turning a diverse fanbase into a caricature maintained by five or so regular 'characters', a meme that the rest of the Prem laughs at on a weekly basis.
Cant say I blame those fans for turning against that sort of thing, and subsequently questioning whether that bloke even is a fan like them given those circumstances (even though, as I said, that AFTV guy apparently does try to interview a few different people from time to time, when he's not focused on gaining ad revenue by devoting the majority of his airtime to that famous 'bludfam' lot).
Maybe if a FanTV channel was set up by the supporters' trust of that particular club, with the ad revenue being used to further the trust's own stake in the club wherever possible - then, maybe it wouldn't generate quite so much instinctive dislike. But as it stands, and on reflection - I'm not surprised that the bubble is starting to burst.
@SteveAWOL - "You're a money maker, you're a money maker, you're a money maker..." , "It's about this (the club), it's not about you."
I never want this drama to end, because laughing at Arsenal has never been more broadly appealing to literally every other football fan.
But I think that reaction does speak to the larger philosophical question at hand, about the nature of supporting a club. And credit to those A*se fans for starting that discussion, whatever their other assorted deficiencies (and whether or not those mongs actually meant to do so in the first place).