The Moonlit Knight
Banned
Same question to you. Who performed better this season, AVB or Redknapp?
-
Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara
Next Spurs manager mega-thread
- Thread starter Billy Nick
- Start date
Same question to you. Who performed better this season, AVB or Redknapp?
I
indianspur
Guest
only in your mind is the that question and the answer to it important
But to make you happy, so you rest easy tonight, I will say that Redknapp outperformed AVB whilst AVB was still here. However since AVB left, Redknapp has been no better than even Terry Connor
I
indianspur
Guest
you think? im not impressed with the raincoat tied tightly at the waist with the belt
the constant crouching is OTT too
mick cooper
Neil Sullivan
MK - thanks, for fighting that particular battle, as it is a thought process along the lines that I have covered before. Particularly heartwarming was the way that the 2 you were dealing with had not one line of argument that made any sense, was backed up by anything tangible and made the pair of them look like schoolboys arguing with a teacher.
A good read, as they say.
you hater you.......
A good read, as they say.
you hater you.......
yeah he's got a good watch doesn't he
Belsizespur
Bobby Zamora
Get that bloke who just beat Bar?ºa.
What's funny is this is the same lot who will claim they will take Martinez/Rodgers/etc. and give them time to rebuild a new team ...
Not often I agree with you, but for me Redknapp has to finish the season before I judge, and even then, is 6th worth firing a manager for at Spurs?
Not sure re the AVB conversation, didn't see enough of his Porto teams to comment, still think he might be worth a look, depending on how progressive his thinking is around stuff that we wouldn't be privy to (e.g. training/preperation/fitness/diet/etc.), Spurs could do with a manager that might be willing to give a 5+ year shift with us.
DubaiSpur
Ian Walker
I'd like to point out that people aren't turning on Redknapp because he looks like finishing in the top six.
They're turning on him because, for so much of the last two seasons, they've seen what the team can really do when they turn it on, only to then suddenly fall away pathetically. Why?
Due to fatigue caused by 'Arry's lack of rotation.
Due to a lack of confidence in the reserve players, caused by 'Arry's reluctance to trust them.
Due to a lack of a coherent game plan, or any sort of tactical framework for the team to fall back on when times get hard, due to 'Arry's lack of desire to train on these things.
Due to a disgracefully low set-piece success rate, due to, again, 'Arry's apparent aversion to, y'know, actually using those big green fields we call training pitches for anything other than five a sides and giggling with Avram Grant.
Due to 'Arry's employment of glorified yes-men as staff and coaches at Spurs Lodge.
Due to a paper-thin squad and terrible options on the bench, caused partly by 'Arry's seeming dislike of buying players he doesn't know much about, while Suarez, Sessegnon, Ben Arfa, Cisse et al sparkle at other clubs.
Due to 'Arry's policy of 'fudging run around a bit', and his helplessness when faced with a bad situation.
Due to 'Arry's refusal to distance himself from the England job.
Due to 'Arry's self aggrandisement at the expense of the club, its players and its fans.
Due to 'Arry's refusal to learn from the season right before this one, when many of the same things happened for many of the exact same reasons.
All these things have contributed to our end-of-season slump, much like they did last season. Add to that 'Arry's utter lack of loyalty to the club, and his tendency to repeatedly mock the fans questioning his management, and the club that employs him, and you're faced with a powder of keg of dislike for the man that only needs the spark of a few bad results to go off.
As for people waxing lyrical about our play, where are they now exactly? waxing lyrical about some other team's style of play while savaging us with every bad result. and what do we have to show for this fulsome praise? Sweet fudge all at present. Will Modric or Bale remember the praise being directed our way when agitating for moves? Will Hazard remember the praise being showered on our flowing football when deciding whether to play in the Europa League or the Champions League?
When do we stop comparing ourselves to Spurs of old and patting ourselves on the back? 'hooray, we finished in the top six three seasons in a row! We've never had it so good!' Yes, we have. We've won the league twice, the FA Cup eight times,the UEFA Cup twice. We've had brief moments of glory punctuated by long spells of mediocrity. Why must we settle for upper mid-table mediocrity because it's slightly better than lower mid-table mediocrity? Why do we have to settle for finishing in the top six and comforting ourselves that it's a good job when you, me and every other fan on the planet knows that this team could have done so much better? So, so much better?
When do we stop wallowing in our own mid-table history and dare to dream? The reason people are turning on Harry is because we were in a position to finish comfortably clear of Arsenal, in third, close to the top two. We had a great squad, with great ability and a potentially great future. We had glorious ambitions of European conquest, and soldifying our place, at last, among the truly big boys. And all we needed to finally do that was a manager who could keep the squad healthy, keep them happy, and keep them motivated when times got rough. A manager who could train them well, and work on all aspects of our play, including set-pieces. A manager who could do something when the chips were down. A manager who could learn from his past mistakes, a la the 2010-2011 season. A manager who could show loyalty to the club who employed him and the players who loved playing for him. A decent manager.
15 out of twenty coaches in the Premier League could have done all of these things. Instead, we got 'Arry, and we are where we are, fifth, three points behind spend-thrift Saudi Sportswashing Machine, and looking short of ideas, energy, motivation or desire. And six points behind Arsenal. From being thirteen points ahead at one stage, which is a nineteen point swing. And it could have been more.
Some people are turning on Harry because they dreamt of finally ending our mediocrity, instead of accepting his guff line that 'we've never had it so good'. That we should have been grateful for what he was giving us.
He's got four games. Win the next one, and the mood changes, confidence returns and a tiny hope flickers. And the dreams will start again. And we have a chance of making it.
If we do, he can leave with the respectful send-off he deserves.
If we don't, his legacy will be the eventual disassembling of the most talented squad we've had in the Premier League era. Simple as that.
They're turning on him because, for so much of the last two seasons, they've seen what the team can really do when they turn it on, only to then suddenly fall away pathetically. Why?
Due to fatigue caused by 'Arry's lack of rotation.
Due to a lack of confidence in the reserve players, caused by 'Arry's reluctance to trust them.
Due to a lack of a coherent game plan, or any sort of tactical framework for the team to fall back on when times get hard, due to 'Arry's lack of desire to train on these things.
Due to a disgracefully low set-piece success rate, due to, again, 'Arry's apparent aversion to, y'know, actually using those big green fields we call training pitches for anything other than five a sides and giggling with Avram Grant.
Due to 'Arry's employment of glorified yes-men as staff and coaches at Spurs Lodge.
Due to a paper-thin squad and terrible options on the bench, caused partly by 'Arry's seeming dislike of buying players he doesn't know much about, while Suarez, Sessegnon, Ben Arfa, Cisse et al sparkle at other clubs.
Due to 'Arry's policy of 'fudging run around a bit', and his helplessness when faced with a bad situation.
Due to 'Arry's refusal to distance himself from the England job.
Due to 'Arry's self aggrandisement at the expense of the club, its players and its fans.
Due to 'Arry's refusal to learn from the season right before this one, when many of the same things happened for many of the exact same reasons.
All these things have contributed to our end-of-season slump, much like they did last season. Add to that 'Arry's utter lack of loyalty to the club, and his tendency to repeatedly mock the fans questioning his management, and the club that employs him, and you're faced with a powder of keg of dislike for the man that only needs the spark of a few bad results to go off.
As for people waxing lyrical about our play, where are they now exactly? waxing lyrical about some other team's style of play while savaging us with every bad result. and what do we have to show for this fulsome praise? Sweet fudge all at present. Will Modric or Bale remember the praise being directed our way when agitating for moves? Will Hazard remember the praise being showered on our flowing football when deciding whether to play in the Europa League or the Champions League?
When do we stop comparing ourselves to Spurs of old and patting ourselves on the back? 'hooray, we finished in the top six three seasons in a row! We've never had it so good!' Yes, we have. We've won the league twice, the FA Cup eight times,the UEFA Cup twice. We've had brief moments of glory punctuated by long spells of mediocrity. Why must we settle for upper mid-table mediocrity because it's slightly better than lower mid-table mediocrity? Why do we have to settle for finishing in the top six and comforting ourselves that it's a good job when you, me and every other fan on the planet knows that this team could have done so much better? So, so much better?
When do we stop wallowing in our own mid-table history and dare to dream? The reason people are turning on Harry is because we were in a position to finish comfortably clear of Arsenal, in third, close to the top two. We had a great squad, with great ability and a potentially great future. We had glorious ambitions of European conquest, and soldifying our place, at last, among the truly big boys. And all we needed to finally do that was a manager who could keep the squad healthy, keep them happy, and keep them motivated when times got rough. A manager who could train them well, and work on all aspects of our play, including set-pieces. A manager who could do something when the chips were down. A manager who could learn from his past mistakes, a la the 2010-2011 season. A manager who could show loyalty to the club who employed him and the players who loved playing for him. A decent manager.
15 out of twenty coaches in the Premier League could have done all of these things. Instead, we got 'Arry, and we are where we are, fifth, three points behind spend-thrift Saudi Sportswashing Machine, and looking short of ideas, energy, motivation or desire. And six points behind Arsenal. From being thirteen points ahead at one stage, which is a nineteen point swing. And it could have been more.
Some people are turning on Harry because they dreamt of finally ending our mediocrity, instead of accepting his guff line that 'we've never had it so good'. That we should have been grateful for what he was giving us.
He's got four games. Win the next one, and the mood changes, confidence returns and a tiny hope flickers. And the dreams will start again. And we have a chance of making it.
If we do, he can leave with the respectful send-off he deserves.
If we don't, his legacy will be the eventual disassembling of the most talented squad we've had in the Premier League era. Simple as that.
Last edited:
It is impossible to call who had the better season due to the fact AVB was sacked halfway through rendering it impossible to draw an objective parallel between the two.
And just to summarise - you are digging into fans for turning against Arry over a 10-15 game bad run (far deeper issues than that but let's simplify it for argument's sake) then in the same breath have tarnished AVB for his bad run of 8-10 games (shorter and slightly better run of games than Arry) during his maiden season in one of the most fickle managerial positions in the world for which he was sacked. I hope you take some time and read / think about that.
Last edited:
You sir, have hit the tickle my balls with a feather
I'm beginning to think the only reason some fans are still left cheering for this man is the fact their expectations are forever rooted in mid-table mediocrity and eternal brickness of the past - i.e. they've been on the receiving end far too long and anything above that is merely a bonus. However - as you say, we must lose this eternal mid-table complex and attempt to use our current glimpse of squad quality and club prosperity instead of always justifying failures on some historical basis and karma
DubaiSpur
Ian Walker
Well, we're about to. Should we not finish in the top four, we will have underperformed for the season as a whole, and, indeed, for the past fourteen to fifteen months, if we take last season's post-February collapse into account.
This squad is capable of finishing third. It has proven it can do so. But it is currently fifth, and, should we (should we) finish the season there, it is two rungs below where we should have finished. Which will probably lead to the sale of a few key members of the squad, necessitating a painful rebuilding process that might or might not yield results. The end of this cycle of Spurs, of this team. Which was supposedly our most talented in the PL era.
Sure, we'll rebuild and come back again...but to come so tantalisingly close to the glory that has eluded us for so long, to feel for the first time on par with the best in Europe...and then to have it snatched away by poor managerial decisions and woeful squad management..that hurts.
Perhaps that's why people are so mad. Not because Harry was, and remains consistently mediocre (Which perhaps would have been tolerated), or consistently below-average, but because he alternates between a mastermind and an inept, clueless, self-aggrandizing chancer with such frequency. He gave us some of the best moments of the PL era, and then, despite every man and his dog pointing them out, proceeded to let his many faults destroy our chances of finally experiencing them on a consistent basis.
We coulda had class. We coulda been contenders, instead of the bums we're looking like becoming.
For the sake of the club, I hope he rams my criticisms down my throat and masterfully guides us to twelve points from the last four games.
At the moment, however, it seems far-fetched.
I hope this finally puts an end to this pipe dream
Jose Mourinho sees 'no reason' to leave Real Madrid
Jose Mourinho says he is not planning to leave Real Madrid this summer as he closes in on winning a league title in a fourth different country.
Real are seven points clear in Spain's La Liga, but Mourinho has been linked to Chelsea and Emirates Marketing Project.
"At the moment my future is not important, but I think I will be here next season," the Real manager said.
"I have a contract with the club and no reason to leave. It is better to stay at a club for four or five years."
The Portuguese was appointed in May 2010, signing a four-year deal, but reports earlier this year claimed he wanted to return to England in the summer.
Mourinho said: "At the end of the season I will have time to speak with the players and the directors and we will decide what is best for me, for the club and for the squad."
After Saturday's 2-1 victory over arch-rivals Barcelona, Mourinho is on the brink of winning the league in a fourth country, after leading FC Porto, Chelsea and Inter Milan to domestic titles in Portugal, England and Italy respectively.
He is also chasing Champions League success with a third club after triumphs with Porto in 2004 and Inter in 2010, although Real will have to overcome a 2-1 first-leg deficit when they face Bayern Munich in Wednesday's semi-final.
"Overall I have not been lucky in semi-finals of the Champions League," he said.
"I lost one with Chelsea [in 2005] due to a goal that wasn't a goal; the ball didn't cross the line. In [2007] we lost on penalties and I lost the semi-final last season because of what everyone knows.
"I don't know if the Champions League is more important than the league, because the best team always wins the league and this isn't always the case in Europe.
"However, the final of the Champions League is the most important thing in football. Tomorrow is almost like a long-awaited final, but I see calmness in the players. I don't like an excess of emotion, nor a lack of it."
Mourinho is also keeping an eye on Tuesday's clash between Chelsea and Barcelona.
"If it were Barcelona against Milan or Arsenal or any other team then it wouldn't matter to me who progressed - I would want the best team to win," he said.
"But because it is Chelsea I feel slightly different. I would like it if the luck went to my old players."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/17829782
Jose Mourinho sees 'no reason' to leave Real Madrid
Jose Mourinho says he is not planning to leave Real Madrid this summer as he closes in on winning a league title in a fourth different country.
Real are seven points clear in Spain's La Liga, but Mourinho has been linked to Chelsea and Emirates Marketing Project.
"At the moment my future is not important, but I think I will be here next season," the Real manager said.
"I have a contract with the club and no reason to leave. It is better to stay at a club for four or five years."
The Portuguese was appointed in May 2010, signing a four-year deal, but reports earlier this year claimed he wanted to return to England in the summer.
Mourinho said: "At the end of the season I will have time to speak with the players and the directors and we will decide what is best for me, for the club and for the squad."
After Saturday's 2-1 victory over arch-rivals Barcelona, Mourinho is on the brink of winning the league in a fourth country, after leading FC Porto, Chelsea and Inter Milan to domestic titles in Portugal, England and Italy respectively.
He is also chasing Champions League success with a third club after triumphs with Porto in 2004 and Inter in 2010, although Real will have to overcome a 2-1 first-leg deficit when they face Bayern Munich in Wednesday's semi-final.
"Overall I have not been lucky in semi-finals of the Champions League," he said.
"I lost one with Chelsea [in 2005] due to a goal that wasn't a goal; the ball didn't cross the line. In [2007] we lost on penalties and I lost the semi-final last season because of what everyone knows.
"I don't know if the Champions League is more important than the league, because the best team always wins the league and this isn't always the case in Europe.
"However, the final of the Champions League is the most important thing in football. Tomorrow is almost like a long-awaited final, but I see calmness in the players. I don't like an excess of emotion, nor a lack of it."
Mourinho is also keeping an eye on Tuesday's clash between Chelsea and Barcelona.
"If it were Barcelona against Milan or Arsenal or any other team then it wouldn't matter to me who progressed - I would want the best team to win," he said.
"But because it is Chelsea I feel slightly different. I would like it if the luck went to my old players."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/17829782
DubaiSpur
Ian Walker
Hmm. Probably bullcrap, but worth posting here all the same, since it comes from the same media that once praised us for our flowing, magnificent, all-conquering football.
EXCLUSIVE
By Wayne Veysey and Greg Stobart
Tottenham players are in open revolt against manager Harry Redknapp’s methods following the calamitous run that is destroying the team’s season, Goal.com can reveal.
A cabal of players, including some of the most senior at the club, have communicated their frustrations via their agents over the last few weeks to chairman Daniel Levy during a run of just one win from nine Premier League matches.
Goal.com understands they have complained about Redknapp’s tactics and match preparation, with one enduring theme being that training during the week is providing little preparation for the weekend fixtures.
It is believed that senior Spurs figures have been so alarmed by the players’ feedback and a catastrophic run of results that they would consider replacing Redknapp as manager at the end of the season, even in the unlikely event that he does not quit Tottenham to become the new England boss.
The club has abandoned plans to try and persuade the 65-year-old to stay at White Hart Lane and will not offer him the four-year ?ú16 million contract they had prepared.
Although Goal.com has learned that Redknapp is far from at loggerheads with his entire squad – reports of a bust-up with Emmanuel Adebayor are wide of the mark - a significant number of players have questioned events on the training ground.
“The players feel they are not going into matches well enough prepared,” a Tottenham source told Goal.com. “For instance, they will practice all week in a 4-5-1 formation and then play 4-4-2 at the weekend. Or vice versa.
“They also feel there is not enough attention to detail and tactics. One common complaint is little or no practice defending set-pieces. There are question marks about the coaching and how much the players are improving through the input of the staff.”
http://www.goal.com/en-gb/news/2896...nham-players-revolt-against-manager-redknapp?
EXCLUSIVE
By Wayne Veysey and Greg Stobart
Tottenham players are in open revolt against manager Harry Redknapp’s methods following the calamitous run that is destroying the team’s season, Goal.com can reveal.
A cabal of players, including some of the most senior at the club, have communicated their frustrations via their agents over the last few weeks to chairman Daniel Levy during a run of just one win from nine Premier League matches.
Goal.com understands they have complained about Redknapp’s tactics and match preparation, with one enduring theme being that training during the week is providing little preparation for the weekend fixtures.
It is believed that senior Spurs figures have been so alarmed by the players’ feedback and a catastrophic run of results that they would consider replacing Redknapp as manager at the end of the season, even in the unlikely event that he does not quit Tottenham to become the new England boss.
The club has abandoned plans to try and persuade the 65-year-old to stay at White Hart Lane and will not offer him the four-year ?ú16 million contract they had prepared.
Although Goal.com has learned that Redknapp is far from at loggerheads with his entire squad – reports of a bust-up with Emmanuel Adebayor are wide of the mark - a significant number of players have questioned events on the training ground.
“The players feel they are not going into matches well enough prepared,” a Tottenham source told Goal.com. “For instance, they will practice all week in a 4-5-1 formation and then play 4-4-2 at the weekend. Or vice versa.
“They also feel there is not enough attention to detail and tactics. One common complaint is little or no practice defending set-pieces. There are question marks about the coaching and how much the players are improving through the input of the staff.”
http://www.goal.com/en-gb/news/2896...nham-players-revolt-against-manager-redknapp?
Enter the Pitbull
Luke Young
Ah yes the infamous "Tottenham Source"...
WHO IS THE MOLE?
WHO IS THE MOLE?
jamonserrano
Terry Yorath
Is that really so hard to talk personally to Levy?
Bang on
