• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Harry Redknapp: The Aftermath

Would you keep Arry after the Season?

  • Yes - He's done well and should be given at least one more season to consolidate our team

    Votes: 25 53.2%
  • No - he's peaked and would hold us back.

    Votes: 22 46.8%

  • Total voters
    47
We did swarm all over them, including when down to 10. Villa parked the bus, Given made that great save, Dunne was outstanding and we got a horrible fluke against us.

As for going with a whimper, from my vantage point the players chased and ran their socks off. Hardly a whimper by any stretch.

The fact that this is singular says pretty much everything.

90 minutes. One great save.
 
We did swarm all over them, including when down to 10. Villa parked the bus, Given made that great save, Dunne was outstanding and we got a horrible fluke against us.

As for going with a whimper, from my vantage point the players chased and ran their socks off. Hardly a whimper by any stretch.


Lots of possession yes but little skilful movement, no real chances created. Same as a lot of our games.
 
Villa are a team so bad that they were easily beatable with us just having 10 men. It realy could'nt have been easier. It was made for Defoe to pepper shots in for the last 20 minutes. We had a chance of glory and Harry blew it. If we get 3rd by some miracle then its by sheer luck. Harry should be sacked whatever. He simply cant take this team any further.
 
So not sure who is going to do the OMT, but what are we going to do about Fulham? No Rose.

Options:

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro------Giovani
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----King/Nelsen---Kaboul--------Gallas
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro---------Bale
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Parker-------Sandro------Modric
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro------VdV
------------Defoe--------Adebayor----------


why no :

----------------Friedel
--------Kaboul Gallas Nelsen
Walker---------------------- Bale
-----------Sandro Modric
-----------------VdV
---------Adebayor Defoe/Saha

?
 
So people have a different view to you and they are idiots, how swell

Well, it usually is the idiots that disagree with me.

But in this case, people have assumed something that could easily be not true, and got irate about it. Getting angry based on guess work. Yes, that's idiotic.
 
Harry says: "It makes for an exciting last day of the season, it's all to play for next week, there are so many different permutations. We can't do any worse than fourth if we win, so that's what we've got to make sure we do."

head_in_hands_man.jpg
 
Well, it usually is the idiots that disagree with me.

But in this case, people have assumed something that could easily be not true, and got irate about it. Getting angry based on guess work. Yes, that's idiotic.

Arrogance, thy name is golfball?


Are you Harry?
 
So not sure who is going to do the OMT, but what are we going to do about Fulham? No Rose.

Options:

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro------Giovani
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----King/Nelsen---Kaboul--------Gallas
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro---------Bale
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Parker-------Sandro------Modric
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro------VdV
------------Defoe--------Adebayor----------

It will be 2 or 3.


Switching to a 4-4-2 after a decent run of results is more than stupid (especially after Arrys post match comments after the Norwich game).
 
I dont particuarly like Harry however:
- his hands were tied by the fact that rose got himself sent off
- we lack options on the bench as our squad has minimal attacking variety (this though is partly Harry's fault)
- bringing on Defoe is only partially useful as he'll never create anything...and bringing him on for VdV means that you're taking off the club's best finisher

That said, Harry's 89th min sub of Praker for VdV was quite simply macaronic.

I do still think we have a decent chance for 3rd as I think Arsenal would win at WEst Brom maybe 3 or 4 times out of ten when they're missing Arteta, Walnut and Sagna. We just have to do our job
 
Harry says: "It makes for an exciting last day of the season, it's all to play for next week, there are so many different permutations. We can't do any worse than fourth if we win, so that's what we've got to make sure we do."

head_in_hands_man.jpg

Hmmmm and what has he said wrong?
 
Villa are a team so bad that they were easily beatable with us just having 10 men. It realy could'nt have been easier. It was made for Defoe to pepper shots in for the last 20 minutes. We had a chance of glory and Harry blew it. If we get 3rd by some miracle then its by sheer luck. Harry should be sacked whatever. He simply cant take this team any further.

Aston '17 draws' Villa. At their ground. With 10 men.

That sort of post fits right into my idiot category. All boxes ticked.
 
Harry says: "It makes for an exciting last day of the season, it's all to play for next week, there are so many different permutations. We can't do any worse than fourth if we win, so that's what we've got to make sure we do."

Read that as well. The guy is a cretin
 
So not sure who is going to do the OMT, but what are we going to do about Fulham? No Rose.

Options:

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro------Giovani
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----King/Nelsen---Kaboul--------Gallas
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro---------Bale
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Parker-------Sandro------Modric
--------------------VdV--------------------
-----------------Adebayor------------------

------------------Friedel-------------------
Walker-----Gallas--------Kaboul--------Bale
Lennon-----Modric-------Sandro------VdV
------------Defoe--------Adebayor----------

SHould definitely be option 2. THe worse thing you can do is move more and more players out of their natural positions. If we're missing a LB then play the next best LB which we have, which would be Gallas. We shouldnt be moving Bale and Modric from their best positions
 
SHould definitely be option 2. THe worse thing you can do is move more and more players out of their natural positions. If we're missing a LB then play the next best LB which we have, which would be Gallas. We shouldnt be moving Bale and Modric from their best positions

Agreed.
 
SHould definitely be option 2. THe worse thing you can do is move more and more players out of their natural positions. If we're missing a LB then play the next best LB which we have, which would be Gallas. We shouldnt be moving Bale and Modric from their best positions
Let's hope Harry learned that from the Everton game
 
SHould definitely be option 2. THe worse thing you can do is move more and more players out of their natural positions. If we're missing a LB then play the next best LB which we have, which would be Gallas. We shouldnt be moving Bale and Modric from their best positions

But then you're doing the exact same thing with Gallas, and CB is one of the most important areas - the backbone of the team and we have been looking solid there with Gallas/Kaboul. I wouldn't want that changed against Fulham who will pose problems and I'm not sure I'd trust King I'm afraid.....
 
Villa are a team so bad that they were easily beatable with us just having 10 men. It realy could'nt have been easier. It was made for Defoe to pepper shots in for the last 20 minutes. We had a chance of glory and Harry blew it. If we get 3rd by some miracle then its by sheer luck. Harry should be sacked whatever. He simply cant take this team any further.


And who do we take off for Defoe with 20 to go? You can't take off Modric - everything goes through him. Take off vdV and half this board would be up in arms. Removing Lennon leaves the team unbalanced. Sandro was our main ball winner and back-tracker, so remove him and you aren't guaranteed possession, and he played the ball forward all day today.

Besides, your call for Defoe to come on with 20 to go is a different argument to the one others are making, which is that it should have been Defoe not Parker that came on...but that was on 89 minutes, not 70 minutes.

So we now have 2 different versions of the apparently obvious thing Harry should have done with Defoe, and neither of them fully explains what the team would look like after either change. There's a fundamental lack of clarity on what exactly the people complaining about today are saying.
 
Back