...Having been a mainstay of Luiz Felipe Scolari’s Seleçao for two years, Paulinho’s time may be up. Against Cameroon on Monday night, he was substituted at half-time to make way for Fernandinho. Zico has been critical of him in recent days, writing in The Guardian: “He is a shadow of the player who last year proved so important in creative and defensive duties. It’s blatantly clear he lacks rhythm and confidence.”
Fortunately for the rest of us, the timing of the substitution allows us to make a handy comparison of the two players. How did Paulinho in the first half stack up against Fernandinho in the second?
Again, on the face of things, it was no contest. Fernandinho helped create Brazil’s third goal, scored the fourth himself, and gave a poise and thrust to Brazil’s midfield that had been so lacking in the first half, when Cameroon briefly threatened a major upset.
And yet, you could also see why Scolari is so enamoured with Paulinho. He runs. He runs and runs. According to the official Fifa statistics after the game, Paulinho covered more ground than Fernandinho, and at a higher pace. Of all his runs, 14 per cent were at “high-intensity” – more than any other player on the pitch. Team-mates love playing with Paulinho. He makes everyone’s job just a little easier.
The problem comes when he gets near the ball. In terms of tackling, passing and creativity, Fernandinho beat him hands down. You could argue that Cameroon faded in the second half, giving Fernandinho more room to play. Still, the statistics tell their own story. Fernandinho’s 22 passes were as many as Paulinho achieved in the entire goalless draw with Mexico. Also, most of Fernandinho’s passes were medium-range passes, the sort that can switch play quickly or form the springboard to a counter-attack. He is also quicker than Paulinho over a short distance.