Well,Walker did something useful, a beautiful goal, but he was pretty dire apart from that! Anyway great to get the three points and be back in fourth. COYS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
He completed 102 passes in the game, second only to Modric. He got more touches (132) than any other player on the pitch.
I'll use your normal line of argument...
Gary Neville = best right back in premier league history , countless trophies, countless medals, great understanding of the game.
Mick Cooper = Glory Glory online resident, lives in Bermuda, swears a lot.
Who's opinion is worth more?
Because Walker scored a great goal 'the rose coloured glasses' come on and some people started lauding him. He was better in the second half, but very edgy in the first and as Mick has said, against almost non-existent oppostion.
Gary Neville's - but I have no idea what his opinion is (I'm watching a fox soccer feed with David Pleat as the co-commentator), but irrespective of what he's said, its his opinion every day.
My opinion is based on what I saw in the game, based on what you could reasonably expect (from the best young footballer in the PL)
I distinctly remember him being embarassed on several occasions, because of poor marking choices, and by letting the player he was supposed to be marking get past him, because of his mistakes.
I don't remember any crosses or passes into the box that resulted in headers or shots on goal (but I don't keep stats or follow the stats engines that are out there.)
I didn't say he had a bad, or disasterous game - just that in my opinion, I would have hoped for better from him, given the opportunities he was presented with.
It is pretty much the same argument that I have with Rose, both fullbacks had an easy time today, with no difficult wide players to deal with, both of them contrived to look laboured.
You can jump down my throat if you want, you have the right do so if you think I am out of line, but tell me where I have been unfair, or over critical. As for the swearing comment, I havent been profane or inarticulate in any of the comments that I have made today - have I? I admit to using industrial language in my condemnation of posters in the past, but I always try to be measured in my comments about Spurs players, as it annoys me when people resort to "he was brick" type comments, and always try to be as objective as I can, if I feel the need to be less than complimentary.
I'm a committed Spurs supporter, and dont seek to rubbish our players, manager, team or club. All I try to do is take part in debates, and always try to explain my POV
Since you've typed all that Glenn Hoddle has since said he feels Walker was the best player out there. He said that he was brilliant defensively and good going forward.
He was voted motm btw. You can have your opinion for sure but you throw that line of reasoning 9 times out of 10 (personally i think it's wrong that just because a former manager or professional says something it's worth more than what you see with your eyes). You seem to think that's the case though so it's only fair it's used against you from time to time.
I don't use that argument every time, only (in my memory) against the "xxxxx was toss/brick/crap" phalanx. As I said, I hate that attitude, so if I ever feel that I have something less than positive to say about a spurs player, I try to stand up for my poiunt of view with reasons for holding them.
I certainly take exception to Glenn Hoddles view that he was the best Spurs player on the pitch (and that hurts for me, because it equates to a committed Christian arguing with Jesus) becuse I believe that at least 6 players had better and more influential games than Walker, certainly with less mistakes and by players who had more demands on them during the game.
What was that handshake between livermore and walker about?!
A decent enough win and performance, but to be frank, if we hadn't beaten Blackburn today that surely would've marked the end of the world. They are the worst team I've ever seen in the Prem, with the most clueless manager.
I think I'm with Mick on this one. Goal aside, Walker had a reasonable game -- a few tackles, some decent passing, getting up and down that wing. However, his crossing needs serious work. If anything, I'd say it's a bit like Azza's a few years back. With some training, Walker could still end up truly world class.
Still, that free kick was IMMENSE. Hope he starts training 'em!