Whether we have previously taken advantage of the home advantage or not is besides the point. Now we're denied that opportunity in crucial games.
Instead of 50-60.000 thousand home fans shouting, singing and intimidating the away team, there will be no noise. No singing. No booing opposition players. Don't tell me that this won't make a difference.
I agree we have benefitted massively as well, of course. A fully fit squad will undoubtedly do us lots of good. But to me that's also just another argument against restarting the season. Because that's not fair either.
Home advantage comment was tongue in cheek and was also re the suggestion of playing derbies in empty neutral stadiums instead of an empty home one, but I do get your points.
I’m sure every club can find positives and negatives in the impact restarting the league will have on them. Some of these will be brought up more vocally post the restart, depending on the clubs results. We do have incidents in normal circumstances, home or away post Europe, playing teams with more rest, different motivations especially towards the end of the season.
There is no perfect solution, if the whole thing is canned then you have the issue of relegation/ promotion / prize money / European qualification to be settled based on a point in time or not at all.
But I don’t kid myself the motive is purely financial, except perhaps to formally confirm Liverpool as champions which is actually worse imo (I‘ll risk a ban from GG by admitting I think this is the one decision that could be made without restarting!)
There does seem to be an element of wanting cake and eating it, clubs dispute does not seem to be related to health concerns, just about how much lovely money they can get and any perceived disadvantage they can counter. Clubs want the league to continue, yet don’t want to play at neutral grounds which may assist having macarons gathering outside and spreading the virus causing a strain on policing. Some were in favour of stopping the season, but only as they had worked out the potential cost of relegation was bigger than the benefit of the prize money on offer for avoiding it.
There will be some bigger challenges ahead, Will Global appetite wane watching the product with the no background noise, would the removal of CL football make the leagues even less competitive or will the bloated squads be harder to manage with less game time to share around. Will the reduction in income, prize money and sponsorship be a good thing for the game or will it be an opportunity for the dopers who don’t rely on genuine club generated income to pull clear?
Ultimately in this instance I think premier league football has been deemed ‘too big to fail’ like banks in 2008, which is a shame as it used to be a sport once.