To me, it looks like we had four players emerge from our youth ranks in 2008-2009, three in 2010-2011, and two in 2012-2013 (although both those players only 'emerged' last season, imo), with Kane emerging this season. It's a regression more than an improvement in the quantity of youth players coming through. And then you claim that all those players mentioned above 'emerged' in 14-15: none of them (none) have impressed either out on loan or in the first-team/Europa League games we've been in, and none have managed to step up to take some squad spaces in a year when half our side was effectively exiled by the manager. And yet these are the players you want to hand Poch as reinforcements next season? This is the 'Class of '92' reborn?
I don't disagree with you re giving Poch only academy options, he should be allowed to buy finished product where he sees fit.
But lets be clear, having 1 player a year make it at PL level would be an accomplishment for most systems, 9 in 3 years is borderline incredible .. no need to downplay that part of it.