We have covered losses too in previous seasons. This season has caught us in a perfect storm of long term injuries just coming back and others being out long term. We cannot cope and we cannot build momentum.
Mangala has improved massively under Guardiola. He was brilliant on one on one's today. They also had fernandinho holding well, breaking up play, our Victor Wanyama.
You're not getting my point, or maybe I'm not putting it across well enough. Mangala has been improved by Guardiola, but not individually - I would argue he is the same player, but that the tactics around him are making him a lot better. He isn't left exposed, he can go into challenges confident that Otamendi, Walker, De Bruyne et all will drop back to help, he can focus on the positive bits of his game (his physicality, more or less) over his shortcomings because Guardiola tailors his tactics to his weaknesses.
I'm not sure how to tailor our tactics to the weakness of Dier and Verts losing half a brain each when Toby isn't around, but Poch hasn't been able to do that in any significant way this season - not at all. And if they had Fernandinho while we are lacking Wanyama, we had Rose while they are lacking *any* left back at all - it is at least as much of a tactical weakness on their part. But Guardiola worked around it expertly, while Poch hasn't been able to do so. This wasn't their best eleven against our weakest eleven, it was two depleted elevens but with one tactically sound and able to cover for their weaknesses, while the other floundered and looked utterly brainless.
I don't disagree with Tripper not being up to it. I said it at the start of the season we shouldn't have sold Walker, because Aurier, as good as he can be, is not the answer yet. He is too reckless.
I said it too. Trippier is not Walker. We would be weaker for his sale, and so it is proving. But Aurier is better than Trippier - and much more suited to days like today, when our wing-backs are required to defend huge stretches of space by themselves. Trippier is *useless* in that situation - not quick enough to get forward or get back, not physical enough to even face Sane, never mind the rest of their team, and not technical enough to evade their press, *despite* his skill on the ball. He is useless. That was clear at half time. Poch knew this. He changed nothing.
Aurier *would have* done much, much better. If your hypothetical is that he would have given away a pen, I still would take that over giving away three goals in *total* down the right-hand side.
So what? They all lost. Can we be better? sure. We are not having a great season so far. But I believe we have mitigating factors which I have already outlined. We need to build some momentum which just seems very difficult at the moment. Bloody Hell you make football management out to be so easy.
So what? Christ, we imploded entirely due to a tactical disaster and the response is 'well, the other teams lost too.' Yes, but they weren't embarassed like we were - sent packing like we were, made to look like bumbling fools like we were.
It would *absolutely* have been that easy to prevent this by fixing the yawning problem down our right, which any and *every* fool could see throughout the game.