This is possibly for another thread, but I can't help myself.
Quite. And that's the reason why these millimetre offside calls shouldn't be reviewed. It's too close to call with current technology. From those two still shots I'm not able to see when the ball leaves N'Dombele's foot. Probably a frame in between - I don't know. And unless the VAR team has access to superior quality images or angles that viewers don't have, neither can they be sure. If they do - well then why don't the viewers get to see what they see? Complete transparency is absolutely instrumental for the trust and credibility of VAR.
Since the rules of football and interpretation of them are changed a few times a week, I don't know whether that excellent guiding principle of giving the attacking team the advantage still stands. Either way, there's no way for anyone to be certain that Son was offside there.
From the still frame the VAR team picked out, he was - but was that the exact moment the ball left N'Dombele's foot? There's no way to tell. And thus there is no way to be sure it was an offside.
Wrong decision #1.
View attachment 10799
This was mentioned a lot on here too last night
Ask any - ANY - sensible football fan why they wanted video refereeing, and they'd say it's a great way to rid the game of blatant refereeing errors. This was one. I can forgive the ref and linesman for not seeing it, but for video referees to not act on this, is unforgivable. It's plain to see even from this slightly awkward angle that both his feet and his hands were outside the area when he caught the ball.
Considering the lengths to which the VAR team went to spot an unspottable offside, it's a disgrace that this blatant violation of the rules - in full view of VAR cameras - wasn't punished.
Wrong decision #2.
Now don't get me wrong, I believe our problems run way deeper than incompetent video refereeing. Even if we'd gone one up I'm not sure we'd manage to win the game. Poor game management, individual errors and lacklustre effort cost us dearly, and that second half display was as bad as anything I've seen from us. We so, so deserved to lose, especially after that final 45 minutes.
However; we certainly weren't given any favours from the VAR team either, apart from their correctly disallowed goal.