I really like Martinez as a guy - he comes across as decent and knowledgeable, and a great club representative, but I remain sceptical, despite the excellent Cup victory.
- They've finished 16th, 16th, 15th and 18th under his tenure (not necessarily in that order)...that's not great really, is it? That's taking into account the limited budget.
- They've consistently conceded huge amounts of goals over the course of every season.
- I'm far from convinced that they've played much good football. I think it's grossly exaggerated.
- His team once lost 8 league games in a row...that's truly abysmal.
- Took about 4 years to find one decent striker in Kone - we're talking Sammon (£600k), Di Santo (£2M), Scotland (£2M), Boselli (£6.5M), Nouha dingdongo (free). He may have been responsible for Kapo, too, at £3.5M - I can't remember.
I like the guy, but as an Everton fan, I'd be wary. It's pretty decent job, so I think there are better candidates.