With the squad he inherited I'd say keeping them up is a success. As soon as someone slightly higher up the table offers him a chance he'll be off again.
That's absolutely right. Had Nigel Adkins gotten Southampton to the play-offs and lost last year, he'd still have a job. It boils my blood to see what happened to him and McDermott. fudging jokes of decisions by people who know nothing about football.
Paul Merson made a good point about Reading last weekend (can't believe I'm putting that cnut in the same sentence as the words 'good point' by the way). He said they are doomed at this point and he's right. Next season they will be in the Championship and when you're looking at candidates to get you back up, Brian McDermott would be up there for any club. The sacking doesn't make sense in the short, medium or long term. They only gave that fella £7.1 million to spend too. How in the name of Saint Michael on a Bicycle can someone be expected to keep a team like Reading in the Premiership having spent £7.1 million? For fudge sake, Harry spent a fortune in January (not to mention what Hughes blew in the summer) while Villa spent that much on Benteke alone. And both those clubs were Premiership teams anyway.
Football is fudging rotten when you see good men and good managers being treated that badly and that idiotically.
Being a good man doesn't really come into it. Adkins was a good man and a decent manager, but with the possibility of appointing Mauricio Pochettino I wholeheartly understand why Southampton sacked him. Pochettino is a promising young manager who got Espanyol to 5th (?) in La Liga and played some impressive football on the way, Adkins had taken them from League 1 and, with such a talented manager ready to come in, you can see why Southampton made the assumption that Adkins could take them no further.
McDermott's sacking was a total joke though. So they get a new big money Russian owner. Woopee. He then does absolutely fudge all to improve a distinctly Championship squad, apart from signing his compatriot Pogrebnyak. They look utter brick all season, destined for relegation, and January does little to change that. So what does this guy do? He rips out the one thing this underskilled group of players have to bind them together, the manager who got them promoted, at the most important point of the season, without having a replacement lined up. Farcical behaviour.
Like Norwich?
Like Norwich?
Being a good man doesn't really come into it. Adkins was a good man and a decent manager, but with the possibility of appointing Mauricio Pochettino I wholeheartly understand why Southampton sacked him. Pochettino is a promising young manager who got Espanyol to 5th (?) in La Liga and played some impressive football on the way, Adkins had taken them from League 1 and, with such a talented manager ready to come in, you can see why Southampton made the assumption that Adkins could take them no further.
Cannot agree with this. Adkins took Southampton out of League 1. That was an achievement albeit not entirely unexpected. To survive in the Championship would have been a good effort last season but he did much, much better than that. Exceeded the wildest expectations of even the most deluded Southampton fans. To stay in the Premiership this season would have been huge and he was on target to do that. Even if he didn't, he deserved to retain his job if Southampton had any class about them. It is disgusting that he was sacked despite doing what even his harshest critics (not that I've heard of any) could only describe as a fantastic job.
The "he took them as far as he could" argument doesn't hold water for me. How does anyone know how far he could have taken them? You can only really judge that on what he has already done with the resources at his disposal. Did he do well with the resources he had? Undoubtedly. No one can argue otherwise. Did Southampton have the side to be doing much better than they were doing at the time of his sacking? You'd be hard pressed to make a case that they should have been. Therefore, you have a manager who was pretty much getting the best out of what he had and had a history of doing so in his time at the club. You want to do better? Give the guy more resources. Best will in the world, Mourinho or Fergie wouldn't get much more out of Southampton than Adkins did. Adkins surely built up enough credit, in over-achieving for two and a bit years, to get the chance.
As for Pochettino. Yes he got Espanyol fifth in La Liga but they were bottom of the table when he left the club. One season of fifth doesn't make a great manager. Ask David O'Leary, ask George Burley, ask Martin O'Neill. Hell, Mike Walker got third with Norwich but wasn't a great manager. This guy doesn't even speak English. If you want a similar situation, look at Juande Ramos with us. That interview with Ramos the morning he got sacked had me wondering how any Spurs player understood him.
Pochettino will not get Southampton anywhere more than lower mid-table if he is lucky and will be gone within 2 years. It's a brainless decision and just shows what little loyalty and class there is in the game.
So once QPRs fate is beyond doubt, how long do we give Harry? Can we see him sticking round in the Championship?
Well, he would be under contract I assume?
So he would have to stay unless the owners deem him surplus to requirements and find a better candidate.
Not many out there may I add..
Reading are close to naming Nigel Adkins as their new manager, Sky sources understand.
crazy sacking McDermott, but at least theyve made a decent choice in Adkins. Of course only if they stick by him even if they go down
they are done, its all about next season for them
We use essential cookies to make this site work, and optional cookies to enhance your experience.