Great post. Posters like scara would have us back to mid 90s Spurs where we were soft as brick. Even when Harry came in we had Modric in midfield but had to add Palacios to shore us up.
I am absolutely sure a scara team put together with his tippy tappy favourites would not win the League. Whereas a Poch team with Sissoko in it could.
Its fair to say prior to this season Sissoko has barely featured in the side, would you agree? Certainly not as a starter.
The logic you and BoL are trying follow would suggest then that we have been a tippy tappy soft as brick side until now.
When we all know that is not the case.
Because if you are honest with yourself you will admit that while Sissoko is indeed an incredible physical specimine, our whole team is made up of strong and combative players. Meaning he isnt the only one. Meaning its not a special talent only he brings to the table.
I think also, if you were really being honest, you would admit previous regulars like Dembele were not only strong and combative, but also intelligent and skillful. Certainly more so than Sissoko.
Which is, really, all people like Scara are getting at.
Controversial? Well it shouldnt be but just take a look at the thread...
I particularly liked this nugget from yesterday:
if people are defending Sissoko more vehemently than other players, there's a very simple reason for that: people are offending Sissoko more vehemently than other players
Its a given, a "fact", to most of you, that this is completely true.
Read back even just the last 5 pages, objectively, and youd find the opposite is actually the case.
People are defending Sissoko FAR more vehemently, and disproportionately, than anyone is "offending" him. Offending being - offering an opinion about his ability and suitability to our team.
They wont have it, so blinded they are by righteous indignation. Personal insults and slights fly from them, and I dont think they even notice.