nayimfromthehalfwayline
Andy Thompson
Sanchez, Vertonghen, Diet, etc.
We have plenty of physical players who can defend and also have technical ability. We're not Stoke or Wimbledon, we can attract players who are both strong and able to play football.
This is the thing - his defensive ability* is promoted as if its completely lacking in the side and as such he is a vital ingredient.
Both false. Its his best attribute, no question, but its not superior to our other regular midfielders who all have a lot to offer besides.
*He is very good, IMO, in a basic Scott Parkeresque "sit in our half and break up anything that comes over the half way line" capacity. I dont think he has superior positioning, tackling technique, or anything like that, I think we have plenty of players who can do the job. His physicality does allow him to cover a big area though. Useful if we are literally all camped in the oppo half an need insurance.