Steff, you know I have a lot of respect for you, so I'll answer you because you just
might pause and listen (others won't)
- Poch may win something at Chelsea, he's got 45 players that cost damn near £800M+, but, he's made that choice, and yes everyman for himself but he was here long enough to know what it's going to cost him with our fans, there is no forgiveness, at least not now, maybe a few years after and that's only likely if he fails (if he succeeds we are a footnote in his career).
He has, indeed, made a choice. I stand by my personal feeling that Arsenal would've been the only absolutely unforgivable choice. This is highly unpalatable, but it is what it is. To be clear, what are we meant to 'forgive' him for? Joining Chelsea? I don't forgive or unforgive him. One of my favourite players of all-time, Glenn Hoddle, moved to Chelsea, became their player manager and went on to put the foundations in place for the monstrouserty they grew into. I not only forgive him, I never thought any ill of him for doing it. I wish he hadn't...I wish Robbo hadn't gone there and made 70 appearances. If this was the Abramovich era I'd be angrier. As it is, they're a curious, messy club and it could be entertaining if they fail as they easily could with Brewster's Millions in charge!
But, I'm going to put something out there that I've refrained from for a while (because I know the reaction). It's such a simplistic view that DonnaC or some people in the board were blocking the return, after all as so many people have pointed out, so easy for Levy to have dealt with the struggles around manager replacement, fan discontent, could have bumped Conte and had Poch lined up and none of this noise would be around, so why?
You want my opinion? First of all, to be clear, I have not said DC 'blocked' it at all. What I believe is there are too many ghosts from the past crumble/breakdown in relationships at upper management levels to have even seen a potential return as tolerable. If you've followed my views on it from the start, I've said fairly consistently that my heart would've enjoyed the love affair returning but my head always told me it was not the right move. I think the club decided for several reasons to go another direction, and I think MP would've demanded a lot more control than. we'd have been prepared to give him. Best for all it didn't happen.
Go watch the David Ornstein video below, time stamp 15:36, 22:09 specific to Poch (and again, this isn't my opinion and Ornstein isn't someone who is complementary to us most days, nor is this a clickbait type interview, it's just a piece of a longer interview)
- Summary, the end of Poch's time was a lot more toxic that we know and it's unanimous at the club that he wasn't/isn't an option
- And I will add my speculation (and I expect people to insult me), if Kane really wanted him, do you not think Levy would have at least talked to him? (Levy in my opinion will do almost anything to keep Kane)
I am not entirely sure why you feel so defensive on these points. They're pretty clear and IMO pretty accurate. I was never in any doubt of the toxicity, what I DID get wrong was how it was handled (or not really handled). Where I believe the club fudged up was in not parting ways in the summer of 2019 given how much dysfunction had been brewing for the previous 6 months. That's where we needed strength in leadership, even against the lemon-and-aura boys like me, who would've had a fit had we parted ways. As it was, Levy and Pochettino came to agreements to stick together and try to go again. Instead of seeing how that played out over a couple of seasons and being brave, Levy got presented his fetish object in Mourinho and sacked Pochettino.
Kane? I hope our chairman is doing his best for the next 5-10 years of the club, not the next couple of years we might still have Kane.
What will upset me the most is people popping up and banging on about what a 'mistake' Levy made in not appointing him again and instead 'allowing' Chelsea to get him. Many of these will be the same people who conversely said it was right to sack him in 2019 when we did. The moment we fudged it was summer of 2019.
I hope Chelsea have a poor time of it, and I hope Poch leaves after a season for a better club.