BrainOfLevy
Michael Carrick
Eh. I disagree with the closing days of the window being the 'right time' to make a move for a player, because a) we're always going to be left scrambling for the few half-decent stalks left in the crop, who may not necessarily be the players we targeted at the start of the window, b) other clubs are still spending like drunken yuppies even as the window winds down - see the new Barkley/Chelsea links, for instance, and c) it sets us back, in terms of squad preparation, because we will always be weaker with the loss of key players sold/squad players moved on for at least the first few games of the season, as we head into August with an incomplete squad, September with our incomings still settling into life in England, October with our incomings not fit enough by our standards, and November with them still working their way into the tempo and tactics of the side. We effectively handicap ourselves in that regard.
I'm not saying the approach has no logic behind it - it's pretty apparent that we do it because of the reasons you listed. But I don't think it's the right approach to take in every scenario, absolutely not.
I also think the last days of the window thing is overblown a bit. If we can do deals in July, we will. (Wanyama, Toby, Janssen) but overall Levy is constantly weighing our position vs that of other clubs. If we need to spend tens of millions, we will do that too, so I'm not convinced it's about penny pinching (waiting until the last day to sign Sissoko didn't help us get him for a cheap price by any stretch of the imagination). I think it's more the case that we need to wait to make sure we get high quality players that we actually need.
It starts with having a defined way of playing, and therefore knowing the type of player required to help us become more than the sum of our parts. Then it becomes about having options in each position as opposed to scattergun signing players that agents have raised to us (which definitely happened before ). And this way, we know who we want, but then it's about making our moves in the right way to ensure we actually get them.
And our strategy, for our position and with our finances, I would say is the right one. We need to let other clubs spend their money and take up places in their squad so they can't realistically bid with us. Examples of us previously failing: making a move for Willian when Chelsea still had a gap in attacking midfield, and leaving us with no room to outbid them. Example of it working: Sanchez talking about how Barcelona were talking to him but there approach was half arsed - they are too distracted with the Neymar situation and trying to replace him. Other clubs like Chelsea had already made their moves with Rudiger etc so we have a clear run. No bidding war. The player sees us as a genuinely great move to progess his career, everyone is happy.
We don't know how many targets we would lose out on if we moved too quickly, but I think the strategy has been pretty consistent since Poch has been in post and we've finally been aligned between boardroom and technical staff. There have been no Willian type disasters. We seem to move efficiently from one target to the next if one doesn't work out, and we seem to be pretty good at getting deals done for good prices without entering unwinnable bidding wars. I can't think of a player we've desperately needed but lost to a Chelsea for example since Poch has been here. But we can now point to some great signings - Sanchez and Aurier hopefully - that we've executed pretty darn well.
I'm not convinced Poch is that fussed about Barkley to be honest. I think it's more if we can make it work we will, if not, we move on. I also don't know if the marginal cost of not signing these players 2/3/4 weeks earlier is now that big a deal. Our squad, aside from right back, should have been strong enough to compete well with Saudi Sportswashing Machine, Burnley and Chelsea. And by all accounts we needed Aurier's legal case to be sorted, and had able back up in Trippier. It's about getting the right players for the long term and I think we are doing that well. We are being very smart and there is a semblance of a plan, of us being in control, which I haven't always got from us, over the Jol, Ramos, Harry, AVB years. Miss out on Willian....get Dempsey? Was that really the plan?