Re: Kyle Walker to Chelsea
What? he has clearly regressed under AVB. The season gone past he was horrendous and the one before that he was young player of the year so GHod knows how he's improved a lot under AVB.
I think he was overrated by some distance during the 11/12 season. Most of the mistakes he's come under scrutiny for under AVB were there in his first season too, but he just wasn't punished for those mistakes as often.
Far from surprising that a highly rated (perhaps overrated) young player has a more disappointing second season. There's always going to be problems when those first errors end up costing the team combined with the pressure and stress from that along with higher expectations and more attention from opponents I think will make a player look worse in their second season quite often.
Walker has bounced back fairly quickly from that almost inevitable first setback, that to me is real progress.
His last couple of months was his best run of games for us I think. He's starting to look more composed when defending, but without losing his energy and enthusiasm. His passing is improving, although slowly (as can be expected).
He is possibly the thickest ever player Ive seen with his decision making on the pitch almost ridiculous sometimes, do think he has bags of potentail though
I think his lack of footballing intelligence gets overstated. He's made some errors and it often seemed he couldn't go a game without making some kind of error, although not always punished. He is very young though and has been playing in a back 4 (and goalie+midfield) that has been far from settled and with much being asked from him both defensively and going forward.
I think his decision making has improved considerably, as can be expected when a young player gains experience at the highest level. I think again that him being overrated in his first season lead to unrealistic expectations that turned out impossible to meet for him.
Like you I think he has a lot of potential, another couple of seasons with us and I think we can have a top class right back on our hands.