We all know it was a mix of a lot of things - some of which he was responsible, others not.
But he didn’t want to be here and his attitude stank at the end - so it’s boring reading it was wrong to part ways, when it was best for everyone.
I think Levy has ultimately taken a massive gamble. Somewhere along the line the unity between Poch and Levy that made us so formidable broke down. Levy has decided that maybe Poch wasn’t the right person to take us forward and at that point, he starts becoming less willing to indulge in the things that would keep Poch happy (ranging from smaller things like not installing the cameras he wanted through to larger issues of squad rebuilding.)
When this happens, obviously Poch would be more likely to want to go himself if he realises he’s on a hiding to nothing. But I don’t think it’s as simple as ‘Poch gave up and wanted out.’ I think the breakdown of their relationship and their different visions for the club, or at least how we could reach our aims, meant that there needed to be a parting of the ways.
Levy is in the hot seat, so gets to make the decisions, reaping the rewards of the ones that go well but deservedly taking the flack when they don’t. And as long as he learns from that each time, he’s fine by me. I think what happened here is that Levy either didn’t think the players should have been struggling as much as they were over the last year and they had more to give, or the funds weren’t there / weren’t willing to be spent to buy the replacements needed. Clearly Poch wanted a lot moved out, clearly Levy either didn’t believe it was necessary or didn’t believe we were capable of doing it financially.
Levy has near enough explicitly said he hired José so that it wouldn’t be a lost season. We have to win something or finish top 4, otherwise this has been a big gamble that didn’t need to take place. We’ve hired a Manager whose record has seemingly gotten worse and worse since his peak, and we’ve sacked one that by all accounts is one of the top coaches in the game. If we are now saying that José needs a couple of transfer windows to get his players in, and to let his mentality shift happen then I am just going to be of the opinion that it was a gamble that didn’t work out. If we lose this season anyway, it’s come at a significant cost to sack a great Manager and hire another, but also at the cost of burning the loyalty of a man who showed it to us when we needed him to the most.
Levy had strategic options. He could have heeded Poch, he could have moved our players for less, he could have made it easier to do the rebuild. He could have let him install his bloody cameras. But he didn’t, and that makes it difficult for Poch to carry on. Levy went the other way, and Jose needs to deliver. I don’t think these performances / results are Jose’s fault, but he was brought here to provide a short term boost and save the season. He acknowledged this - he said the squad was a top 3 squad. Him getting this job came at a cost of losing a man that did so much for us over such a consistent period. It needs to work and we need to save this season with a trophy or the top 4. If we don’t and we end up finally rebuilding anyway it’s a failed gamble as far as I’m concerned.