I would have taken him as 2nd choice in the summer - before I realised Gazza was very goodI have always thought Ben Foster is a good keeper and has been for a long time ( MOM for Utd in the final against us) Not for one minute am i saying we should get him though.
Cech, are you serious? the guy is not in the top 10 keepers in the PL, hasn't been for at least 2-3 years ...
De Gea is the best keeper in that list and he has had a really brick first half of season (basically most games before his blinder with us)
I don't think any of the other 3 are miles ahead (as I said, De Gea/Neuer were above others for while, those guys are all 2nd tier like Lloris)
And to your specific comment re competition, do any of those sides have a back up keeper really pushing for a first team spot?
Here's the reality check, keeper position is not a priority for us
- Even if we have 150M to spend in summer, nobody is even going to contemplate a keeper buy other than perhaps releasing Vorm and getting a young English keeper that doesn't take up a overseas spot.
It feels like we give the opposition a free goal in every game lately.
Premier league clean sheets this season:
Alisson 13
Ederson 10
Kepa 10
Hugo Lloris 8
Not that bad...
All this talk of De Gea playing great against us is wrong, IMHO.
Aside from one very good save with his feet we put EVERY SINGLE BLOODY SHOT right into his arms.
Whole goal to shoot at? Aim at the keeper...
We made him look incredible, fact is had Lloris let in any of the shots De Gea stopped we would have been livid (barring that one very good save).
But of course, now he is a worldie again...
And despite the mistakes he’s still made a ton of amazing saves that have kept us in games. I’m sure none of us on here ever make a mistake at work.
and when you take into account or two first choice cbs haven't played together that much and its been two very young replacements in front of him.
There was an incident against Watford where Deeney shot from a tight angle and tried to claim a corner off Lloris, it looked to me then that he was covering past the near post which leaves more of the far side open.True... although Jenas did some good analysis on Match of the Day 2 and pointed out how much better de Gea’s positioning was than Lloris, who was stood ahead of his near post for their goal which gave Rashford a much bigger gap to shoot for than any of our players had that day.
Alas yes, we miss the spaghetti monster.I still think the issue lies more in the rather pourous midfield in front of them...
He isn't making more mistakes, everyone has just got a bit carried away with gazzaniga and are being over critical of LLoris.
LLoris always made mistakes, otherwise we wouldnt of been able to buy him and keep him.
Need to wait for Toby to leave, sort out the RB issue both another season, and then assess if we need to change the Keeper
We dont need to add Gazzinga into current situation, its neither in his or our best interests
I still think the issue lies more in the rather pourous midfield in front of them...
Lloris often has poor positioning i.e. too far outside his post etc. I think it is because he sprints out so far and so fast, he obviously would find it harder to keep his bearings re: the goal.True... although Jenas did some good analysis on Match of the Day 2 and pointed out how much better de Gea’s positioning was than Lloris, who was stood ahead of his near post for their goal which gave Rashford a much bigger gap to shoot for than any of our players had that day.
Had a good game today, 1 or 2 great saves. And another clean sheet.