Harry Kane MBE

[Mikey10]

Wasn't it reported, for what it's worth, that Lewis wasn't happy for Kane to walk.

Irrelevant, given that “he’s got nothing to do with the club.”

 

[Bishop]

Rubbish. Greaves name is still there. The list just emphasises the reality of them being one of the very best that has scored goals in this league. Shearer won’t suddenly be erased if Kane surpasses him, what nonsense.

No one is saying winning trophies is not the purpose of football. The point was it is a harder achievement being all time top goal scorer than winning a trophy with Bayern - and I think that’s obvious isn’t it?

But see you didn't answer my question about who the top scorer before Shearer was probably because you don't remember who it was. With time details fade, the only things remembers are those that are etched in stone. A goal scorer record is not, it can be superceded.


And who cares whether it's harder or not (your perspective). You don't win for doing it the hard way, you win by winning. Period.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

 

[Bishop]

it was probably always Shearer wasn’t it, well other than Brian Deane on day 1.

Iirc Andy Cole held the record for a period of time before Shearer took it. But the confusion adds to my point, over time the previous holder gets forgotten about. Only the current holder matters in time.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

 

[Dicko]

https://twitter.com/x/status/1686326461513236480

 

[Baleforce]

Iirc Andy Cole held the record for a period of time before Shearer took it. But the confusion adds to my point, over time the previous holder gets forgotten about. Only the current holder matters in time.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

turns out, it was Sheringham for a while too

 

[Finney Is Back]

I thought he was valued at £100m not Euro's ??

Only by THFC. Is clear from lack of bids that he's not valued that high.

 

[SpurMeUp]

But see you didn't answer my question about who the top scorer before Shearer was probably because you don't remember who it was. With time details fade, the only things remembers are those that are etched in stone. A goal scorer record is not, it can be superceded.


And who cares whether it's harder or not (your perspective). You don't win for doing it the hard way, you win by winning. Period.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

One thing is for sure, people are far more likely to remember the top PL scorers than those who won a trophy at Bayern in 2024! It is a far more interesting achievement too.

 

[Baleforce]

Only by THFC. Is clear from lack of bids that he's not valued that high.

I expect a few others are just waiting to see where the fee lands.

As soon as we accept I expect United will get involved, Chelsea too.

 

[Lemonade Money]

I expect a few others are just waiting to see where the fee lands.

As soon as we accept I expect United will get involved, Chelsea too.

I'm assuming Levy has told Kane, Man U and Chelsea that there is no way he will sell to a PL club, otherwise there would surely be noises? Just look at the amount of 'Why aren't Man U in for Kane?' articles at the moment.

 

[DTA]

I'm assuming Levy has told Kane, Man U and Chelsea that there is no way he will sell to a PL club, otherwise there would surely be noises? Just look at the amount of 'Why aren't Man U in for Kane?' articles at the moment.

the thing is if Man U offer 120m+ I would rather sell to them than to Bayern for 80m.

 

[Bishop]

One thing is for sure, people are far more likely to remember the top PL scorers than those who won a trophy at Bayern in 2024! It is a far more interesting achievement too.

English fans maybe. German fans and Bayern fans will remember who won a trophy at Bayern in 2024. Likewise someone like myself who watches a variety of football and has an interest in football outside of just the British Isles will know as well.

But sure the top scorer yes, but Kane might not always been the top scorer just like Andy Cole isn't anymore not is Sheringham.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

 

[Bedfordspurs]

English fans maybe. German fans and Bayern fans will remember who won a trophy at Bayern in 2024. Likewise someone like myself who watches a variety of football and has an interest in football outside of just the British Isles will know as well.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

I actually think German fans will know who wins the league when Bayern don’t
Other than that it will be one of many in a row… much like it’s going here with city

 

[Finney Is Back]

I don’t think we are tinkling about, we want to keep him, but no reason to panic as if he does go we have Son and Richi, who are both really fudging good.

We're not tinkling about but it seems that the club needs the money from the Kane sale to purchase any more players to continue the rebuild.

 

[DubSpur]

We're not tinkling about but it seems that the club needs the money from the Kane sale to purchase any more players to continue the rebuild.

They need the money from sales, not necessarily the sale of Kane.

 

[Baleforce]

They need the money from sales, not necessarily the sale of Kane.

and room in the wage pool

 

[Jurgen the German]

I don’t think we are tinkling about, we want to keep him, but no reason to panic as if he does go we have Son and Richi, who are both really fudging good.

I’ll give you Son but Richarlison is nowhere near Kane’s level.

 

[DubSpur]

I’ll give you Son but Richarlison is nowhere near Kane’s level.

We're not getting anyone near Kanes level when he leaves, you need to move on from expecting anything above a striker that gets around 15 goals a season.

 

[Bishop]

We're not getting anyone near Kanes level when he leaves, you need to move on from expecting anything above a striker that gets around 15 goals a season.

The issue is we don't know if Richy is a 15 goal a season guy. I think he can be, especially if the service is good but it's far from certain.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

 

[Jurgen the German]

We're not getting anyone near Kanes level when he leaves, you need to move on from expecting anything above a striker that gets around 15 goals a season.

We don’t even know if he can get 15 let alone anything close to Kane’s numbers.

 

[Bedfordspurs]

The issue is we don't know if Richy is a 15 goal a season guy. I think he can be, especially if the service is good but it's far from certain.

Sent from my XQ-BC72 using Fapatalk

Everything is TBF
Losing Kane is an unknown