Re: Gareth Bale
The circumstances have to be in our favor for us to be able to 'make' a player stay - hence Berbatov and Carrick both leaving in the first windows they wanted moves and why since then we do our best to regularly lengthen players contracts.
But the original point stands that it's never as simple as just making then stay.
It really is. That is exactly what happened in the Modric to Chelsea saga 2 years ago.
EDIT: And Modric was openly asking for a move, Bale has said nothing of the sort. Only that he would listen to Madrid if we accepted their offer. What pretty much any player in the world would say.
No, you give them a long contract and sell them with 2 years left, like we did with Modric, Berba and probably Carrick too.
The circumstances have to be in our favor for us to be able to 'make' a player stay - hence Berbatov and Carrick both leaving in the first windows they wanted moves and why since then we do our best to regularly lengthen players contracts.
But the original point stands that it's never as simple as just making then stay.