Can any of us really provide evidence on a lot of stuff that goes on though? Doesn't stop people criticising Sherwood for example.
Well if the Mods were trying to stop people from criticising XY and Z im sure there'd be some evidence seeings as everything is saved and stored on site - my guess is there wouldn't be any though as i don't think that's how we run the site.
As for Baldini i think it's pretty simple, if someone wants to say he fudged up with buying XY and Z then there needs to be something that you can use to back up the idea that it was him that chose that player to be signed otherwise your position isn't really very strong