SpurMeUp
Les Howe
I don't know as I don't know what could have been done. Visitors were stopped, but they could hardly stop staff, nurses and doctors visiting. These were old people who needed constant care and attention that has to involve intimate contact.
The care homes have been a problem everywhere that has had community transmission and high death rates. It's hard to see a particular choice the government made that can be criticised, at least at this point in time. The blanket you should have done something criticism is rather empty without a specific error, especially as other countries have had the same problem.
Number 1 is preparedness. Chinese people were dying in droves, then Iranians, then Italians. The UK acted fast with some things - we were one of the first to make a test. We had exceptional biomedical resources in the UK. Yet we dropped the ball getting prepared. A huge criticism is the government seeing what was happening and preparing well for it. That is a 'particular choice that can be criticised'.
Two, when it was clear we were unprepared, we didn't get testing setup nearly quick enough, or ensure it was being used. This was an infrastructure and logistics failure rather than a science issue. The UK has so many labs able to test.
Three, despite government advisors flagging up care homes as vulnerable - covid affects older people we knew this in Jan - nothing was done to strengthen our defense. Worse, we undermined care homes by sending sick people into the system.
Four, the government did not rally the nation, and use the resources at its disposal. Whether that was getting PPE, making it, using labs around the nation etc. We did get a volunteer army for the NHS, but so much more could have been done.
Five, messaging, it was not clear, no time was given for announcements to be implemented and the nation didn't feel like it was pulling together to achieve an aim (imo)
Are these 5 specific enough? I'm shooting from the hip, but to me it has been clear from the off, the government have been reacting, rather than taking effective control. It was a hard task, but there are clear things that could have been done a lot better.
Last edited: