He is an unorthodox drummer. I think good/bad becomes subjective (he's much better than you think BTW). Bill Ward - monster with the swing and for me, blows Neil Peart away, but Peart is (pound for pound) a superior technical drummer.
I am biased, but equally, I think LU cops brick simply because he's LU and simply because "people" say it. I tell you this...if I ever personally see anyone wearing one of those disgraceful t-shirts involving Cliff, they're hitting the deck or running from me!
Just to keep this on track, Sissy did well Sunday. You can only play the game/team you're playing. I know what's coming in response...