• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

Ange in or out?

Ange in or out?

  • In

    Votes: 82 43.4%
  • Out

    Votes: 107 56.6%

  • Total voters
    189
I think I'd have to agree with Tommy that a league cup and top 10 would be a half decent season. Cant see us getting top 4/5 next season no matter who comes in.

Ange or otherwise we eventually need to be in the CL semi regular to even have designs on winning the odd cup though. I get the two letter CL are tainted with some because its associated (wrongly in my opinion) with our inability to convert, but in all of football over than the Tim Cup and the Copa Del Ray in their respective country, the majority of trophies in this country by a mile are won by those occupying the top slots in the league.

Our accounts also demonstrate that.

A mix of both will do me, I don't think we are ready to win the league but a cup win and top 4/5 would be utopia for me next season
 
I think I'd have to agree with Tommy that a league cup and top 10 would be a half decent season. Cant see us getting top 4/5 next season no matter who comes in.

Would you have settled for that under pochettino?
His time was looked at as that team and redknapps should have won a trophy aswell as getting cl football.
Now we'd settle for mid table and a trophy? If we don't win the trophy what then?

No sorry. I want us to be the best team in the world. Bring in the qataris. Bring in ancelotti. Bring in world class players. Bring in true glory years.
 
because a new manager deserves time for a proper pre season, especially if we are gunning for CL the following season.

So far the main names linked are Iraola, Thomas Frank, Marco Silva and Francesco Farioli (Ajax).

I think I’d rather take a chance on given the manager who just won us a European cup a chance to build.
 
League cup won't do. It would be great don't get me wrong. But the money from cl is so huge we can't be losing £100m and letting villa/Saudi Sportswashing Machine/villa get an extra £100m. That's a £200m swing in revenue. With those clubs willing to spend every penny of it.

I don't wan't to go back to the 90's being a mid table club. Winning a league cup. I want us to be challenging on every front. I want us to dominate.
i would be happy if we are a shoo-in for top four every season. cups are bonus - winning the EPL and CL is the goal. And we've come close on both fronts recently.
 
Would you have settled for that under pochettino?
His time was looked at as that team and redknapps should have won a trophy aswell as getting cl football.
Now we'd settle for mid table and a trophy? If we don't win the trophy what then?

No sorry. I want us to be the best team in the world. Bring in the qataris. Bring in ancelotti. Bring in world class players. Bring in true glory years.

Settle is your word, not mine. I see what I outlined as good progression on the journey to hopefully winning the league one day — even if I’m not sure we ever will.
 
So far the main names linked are Iraola, Thomas Frank, Marco Silva and Francesco Farioli (Ajax).

I think I’d rather take a chance on given the manager who just won us a European cup a chance to build.

yeah i respect your preference. i just don't think its sensible to continue with a coach that has 2 years of very poor records and worse football to watch.

also, now that we have champions league, i believe that number of candidates would have increased quite a bit, along with our transfer budget
 
Settle is your word, not mine. I see what I outlined as good progression on the journey to hopefully winning the league one day — even if I’m not sure we ever will.

As i said we'd be losing £100m and giving it to forest/Saudi Sportswashing Machine/villa. We wouldn't progress we'd regress. Making it harder to compete with them.
We're already behind them.
 
People will complain for sure. By that point many will point to this season and say look at what he has done and then the usual there are no decent options during mid-season...

I still can't see, over what happened so far, how he could achieve what you said in the first paragraph. The level of opposition was poor this year in the UEFA cup. We have made a massive, massive achievement but haven't played at a very high standard so to me, that means very little in terms of our chances of success next season. That being said, I agree it's a poor timing to make that bold decision, although IMO that's what should be done. So fully expect to see the Ten Haag situation next season. But then, stranger things have happened, so again I am happy to be proven wrong again.
Ten Haag situation? The situation where they've gone lower in the league and won diddly squat since he won them the FA Cup against Emirates Marketing Project. Pretty obvious Ten Hag wasnt/isn't the problem at that club....
 
Would you have settled for that under pochettino?
His time was looked at as that team and redknapps should have won a trophy aswell as getting cl football.
Now we'd settle for mid table and a trophy? If we don't win the trophy what then?

No sorry. I want us to be the best team in the world. Bring in the qataris. Bring in ancelotti. Bring in world class players. Bring in true glory years.

No what I meant is following the disaster of this season, I would settle for League cup and top 10 next season as I feel it's too much ground to make up to get 4/5/6 next season.

That's just me trying to be realistic but I do agree with the rest of your views
 
No what I meant is following the disaster of this season, I would settle for League cup and top 10 next season as I feel it's too much ground to make up to get 4/5/6 next season.

That's just me trying to be realistic but I do agree with the rest of your views

I get it. Just we took so long to get back to being considered one of the big 6 (city and chelsea being doped).
I don't want to go back to being a midtable club. Saudi Sportswashing Machine, villa and forest are now being doped.
Utd are in trouble. As big as they are they have a massive job on their hands trying to stay afloat financially. Will have to sell players just to balance the books. Which will be difficult the wages they are on.
If the clubs coming up decide to really go for it and are smart. Next season could be very competitive.
 
No what I meant is following the disaster of this season, I would settle for League cup and top 10 next season as I feel it's too much ground to make up to get 4/5/6 next season.

That's just me trying to be realistic but I do agree with the rest of your views

That IMHO is a good level to be aiming at for next season if the football improves.
I've seen some levels of expectations that I think are only setting us up to fail.
Top four and CL qf. That's before a ball is kicked or we know our transfer business.
We can achieve those, but they should not be seen as minimum requirements.
 
That IMHO is a good level to be aiming at for next season if the football improves.
I've seen some levels of expectations that I think are only setting us up to fail.
Top four and CL qf. That's before a ball is kicked or we know our transfer business.
We can achieve those, but they should not be seen as minimum requirements.

It's not expectation. It's ambition. Which for the resources we have spent under ange compared to other clubs should be achievable.
 
yeah i respect your preference. i just don't think its sensible to continue with a coach that has 2 years of very poor records and worse football to watch.

also, now that we have champions league, i believe that number of candidates would have increased quite a bit, along with our transfer budget

2 years of very poor records??? Honestly mate…he’s finished 5th and won a European trophy! Your expectations are outrageous, and none of the managers I’ve mentioned have ever achieved either of those things.
 
We won a cup, which, when we started, we were one of the favourites to win. This is the easiest of cups to win when the opposition is taken into account. The Champions League is at a completely different level and is comprised of teams that are on par with the Premiership top five and better. The current team under Ange is miles away from that level, as he has demonstrated in our league form.

I'm fed up with his 'Angeball' of panic defending, tippy tappy around both boxes a lack of shooting or the confidence to shoot (when was the last time Solanki had a shot from outside the box?), pressing from the front and leaving huge gaping holes behind, fullbacks stranded up field, Son and Solanki being sooo sloooow, they're well past it and so on.

Yes, amazing we won a cup, but this has been the most depressing season of watching my team I can remember. I don't want any more of it.

Daniel, please get rid.

I keep seeing this about the CL.
Yes it the top teams I Europe in it.
It also has a lot of dross.
36 teams, only a handful at the very best can be expected to win it.
City and Real Madrid are usually favourites, so when they win it does it demeanor their achievement?
 
I predicted, before the game last week, that the Euphoria that stemmed from a win would understandably cloud the judgement on Ange. I didn't exactly have to be Nostradamus either. I have softened on Ange since Wednesday. I have seen some humility from him and the love that his players feel for him. Also impressed how he has supported a number of players such as Biss and Johnson who became whipping boys for the anger with this season's league performances.

It's difficult for the club to sack him without heaping pressure on his successor. The context around the trophy win will not matter to most fans.

But when the joy has died down logically there are still questions that have not been answered

1) He has won a trophy and good on him. But there were specific circumstances around that - he was able to focus on it, forgetting the league entirely and protecting his preferred defence for multiple games. I doubt he will be able to replicate those circumstances next season nor will he be cut the same slack. Especially if Paratici replaces Munn as is widely expected.

2) He played a certain way in the Europa League knock outs that is not his preferred style because his back was up against the wall. On the one hand that shows pragmatism, but we know he favours his attacking playing style. Can he fine tune it? Unfortunately he hasn't really succeeded in doing that over the last 2 seasons. And that is a worry for me. I don't necessarily see this as an Alex Ferguson moment.

3) Can he cope with playing in multiple tournaments, the injuries that that will entail, and ensure the players coming in will adapt to his preferred style? We know he hasn't done that well this season.

This season has been an anomaly so it's very difficult to make a decision about Ange's future. But I suspect once the league starts and he has to once again focus on multiple priorities, we will see the same issues arising. My preference is for him to go now by mutual consent, head held high and we bring in a different coach now rather than midway through next season. But I think he will stay. I am less annoyed by that than I would have been before this week.
 
Last edited:
You never stop learning. I get that we are all euphoric at a trophy. But I find it incomprehensible that an apparently large number of supporters are now suffering from amnesia. I have watched every game for the last two years. I do not see how anyone looking at our performances can see a progression in a direction that sustained success is over the horizon. We play Angeball and always look like conceding. See, record number of defeats this season and form after league game 10 last season.

But he won a trophy… As others have pointed out, so did Ramos and Ten Haag. Has Ange earned the right to another year? I could understand that sentiment more if we had overwhelmed United with a display of dominance to vindicate Angeball. But the reality was an eked out desperate defensive display.

Look I would have loved Ange to be the guy. I would have loved Ossie to have been a success. But the reality,imho, is that we can do better with a different coach who knows how to defend without sacrificing our ability to attack or vice versa.

In my view it will be a sad state of affairs if we squander our current enhanced status by backing the wrong guy. But I couldn’t understand the attraction of Brexit or Trump so what do I know 😉
 
Back