ringo
Tim Sherwood
Re: ***The Official AVB Discussion Thread***
Regardless of where you play certain players, they still have the same abilities, characteristics and so on. Stick Dembele out on the left, but he is not going to be doing much sprinting down the wing, beating a man and whipping a cross in. Dawson's a warrior in his own area, great at getting in the way of shots, depriving the opposition of the ball etc. But in a tight midfield with quick passing and no time on the ball, he'd be poor.
When you're between transfer windows - you have to start with players' strengths and weaknesses, what they can and can't do well, and then fit the system to the players. (And if your intended system fits neatly with players qualities, then that's great.)
From what I have seen so far, neither Dembele, Paulinho, or Sandro appear to be midfielders that make quick short sharp runs into space, play quick one twos, burst into the box at pace. They all seem relatively ponderous in their play, albeit physically solid. Ironically of the three I'd say that Sandro is most inclined to release the ball forward quickly. So you could call Dembele or Paulinho an attacking midfielder, but they still wouldn't play like one.
Then we have Holtby, who is quicker in his movement and play, but still shows no great signs of getting into the box and scoring, or sliding the balls through to Soldado. And then Eriksen and Siggy who can both play centrally, but still seem to want a bit too much time on the ball in advanced areas. (Not seen Lamela enough centrally to comment -he seems to like a one-two but doesn't have anyone to play them off.)
So I think we have lots of players with good defensive and possession based skills for deeper midfield roles, but very few midfielders who can link the play up between the wide players and CF, or just with the CF. And with two midfielders who have DM abilities, we will often only have three or four players attacking, and Soldado often pulls to the edge of the box, with no one making a compensating run into it. So we need more offensively capable players on the pitch of a certain type.
Regardless of where you play certain players, they still have the same abilities, characteristics and so on. Stick Dembele out on the left, but he is not going to be doing much sprinting down the wing, beating a man and whipping a cross in. Dawson's a warrior in his own area, great at getting in the way of shots, depriving the opposition of the ball etc. But in a tight midfield with quick passing and no time on the ball, he'd be poor.
When you're between transfer windows - you have to start with players' strengths and weaknesses, what they can and can't do well, and then fit the system to the players. (And if your intended system fits neatly with players qualities, then that's great.)
From what I have seen so far, neither Dembele, Paulinho, or Sandro appear to be midfielders that make quick short sharp runs into space, play quick one twos, burst into the box at pace. They all seem relatively ponderous in their play, albeit physically solid. Ironically of the three I'd say that Sandro is most inclined to release the ball forward quickly. So you could call Dembele or Paulinho an attacking midfielder, but they still wouldn't play like one.
Then we have Holtby, who is quicker in his movement and play, but still shows no great signs of getting into the box and scoring, or sliding the balls through to Soldado. And then Eriksen and Siggy who can both play centrally, but still seem to want a bit too much time on the ball in advanced areas. (Not seen Lamela enough centrally to comment -he seems to like a one-two but doesn't have anyone to play them off.)
So I think we have lots of players with good defensive and possession based skills for deeper midfield roles, but very few midfielders who can link the play up between the wide players and CF, or just with the CF. And with two midfielders who have DM abilities, we will often only have three or four players attacking, and Soldado often pulls to the edge of the box, with no one making a compensating run into it. So we need more offensively capable players on the pitch of a certain type.