I think if AVB considers it worthwhile considering his experience in football (I know he isn't experienced in the grand scheme of things, but he must learn a hell of a lot through various coaching seminars and discussions with peers in terms of coaching, team building etc) then I don't think outcasting players is necessarily a bad thing or something that is only bad. I guess it helps to create a single mindset among the players and not have any bad eggs in the squad (no Jose pun intended).
Ramos did it, and it didn't necessarily work but it can be easily argued he failed for other reasons. I just think, are our players going to think 'what a ****, he's outcasted Ade and Benny, I don't like him and I'm not going to play for this club anymore' or are they going to think '****, if I don't stay focussed I will be out on my ****, and will have ****ed away a great opportunity at a top club in one of the best leagues in the world.'
I would argue that if AVB did this last year, the former would have been the collective mindset of the team, and that's what happened at Chelsea. But this year, he has proven himself to the players, and to the board. The players know now that if they kick up a fuss that they aren't as close to Levy like Chelsea's were to Roman, so there is no way of going around the manager. He has the authority and is going to be backed, and any questioning of that will reflect badly on the player in question, not on the manager. I'd argue that he has handled it diplomatically because he gave Ade, Benny, Lennon and Defoe ample opportunities to play last year. He didn't ship them out immediately. He gave them a year to prove themselves and to get to know their personalities.
If he thinks players are coasting and doesn't want that attitude in the squad then I trust him to kick them out to be honest. He wouldn't be doing it to talented players lightly, he will have had a year to really get to know them.
Do you think someone like Holtby is a sulker or a moaner? Will he ever shirk? Not a chance. He is going to get his opportunities. We need a squad of players like that, chomping at the bit to get in the team. Ade and Benny are reflective of Harry's years, languid players capable of absolute brilliance and maddening inconsistency on occasions. Needing an arm around the shoulder or preferential treatment to get them fired up again. I'm fine with having an entire squad full of mentally tough bastards who won't take any **** from any of their team mates. It's how champions are made.