I have no idea whose opinions you're arguing against, but they're not mine.
What parts of my post(s) made you think that my opinion is that buying Sneijder would be the equivalent investment to throwing money down a hole? If anything I wrote could be seen to say that please let me know, obviously I must find a way to make myself clearer in the future if that's the case.
I didn't say that how many clubs are interested is "the yardstick of a successful signing". Obviously what a player can do for us is the important part. I just asked the question why, if this is such an obviously good deal, more clubs aren't interested?
I'm obviously not his agent. If you're going to be outright silly at least make an effort to be somewhat funny or original. The interest and negotiations from Galatasaray have been widely reported with quotes from at least Galatasaray. Does that indicate that a lot of big clubs are after him?
Brainecslipse, throughout this thread you have expressed an opinion largely focused around the issue of 'investment' and whether this purchase would be a worthwhile 'outlay' - subsequently you had 'softened' your view but the overall premise remains. Please correct me if I'm wrong, or missing your point. For me personaly, he's a quality player who would improve our team substantially, that is the main concern around such a marquee signing (for lack of better word). VdV was one, Lloris is another, etc.
Few points below
- how do you know only one club are interested simply because that's what is reported in the press. Even in the article, I posted further up he makes mention to the 'offers' he's received, choosing to keep those private. But even if Galatasaray were the only club 'interested', I still fail to see how that can be considered disadvantageous to him as a player/transfer (within our context, of course). To answer your question - I'm not sure why (according to you) no other big clubs are interested although some reasons could include - lack of starting 11 availability, lack of funds (Italian clubs are desperately trying to cut costs and have already stated no big transfer are envisaged for the foreseeable future), the two clubs in Spain have plenty in his position, while the only English clubs who can accommodate him are us and Liverpool (Utd have Kagawa and Powell, in addition to Cleverly who can also fill in that position as well as Rooney who drops in the hole when RvP starts). Not sure he wants to go to Germany.
- what does any of that have to do with us and his quality as a transfer / player?
- how many 'big' clubs were interested in VdV and Lloris for example?
Last edited: