Kandi1977
Garth Crooks
CorrectI thought that the defender has to be deemed in control of the ball in order to play opponents onside?
As the Leicester player merely stuck a leg out to block Benteke' shot.
CorrectI thought that the defender has to be deemed in control of the ball in order to play opponents onside?
As the Leicester player merely stuck a leg out to block Benteke' shot.
No, you are wrong about that. The defender didn't pass the ball. It was a block/deflection, not an intentional act, thus it's offside.
I've never heard anything about being in control of the ball. Only that the touch has to be intentional.I thought that the defender has to be deemed in control of the ball in order to play opponents onside?
As the Leicester player merely stuck a leg out to block Benteke' shot.
If only all match days of the Premier League were this good! What a great day for us.
If I'm understanding example 11 on the FA' site correctly, as the Leicester defender was trying to block Benteke' shot then that made Lucas offside when he attempted to latch onto the rebound.I've never heard anything about being in control of the ball. Only that the touch has to be intentional.
It would be hard to argue that the defender didn't do what he wanted when he stuck a leg out there.
A player in an offside position receiving the ball from an opponent, who deliberately plays the ball (except from a deliberate save), is not considered to have gained an advantage.
I see. I didn't realise they'd specified a save as something separate - that's a new one on meIf I'm understanding example 11 on the FA' site correctly, as the Leicester defender was trying to block Benteke' shot then that made Lucas offside when he attempted to latch onto the rebound.
http://www.thefa.com/~/media/files/...-interpretations-of-the-laws-of-the-game.ashx
It's the same as in the rule for a pass back to the GK. If it's intentional he can't pick it up, if it's not, he can.I see. I didn't realise they'd specified a save as something separate - that's a new one on me
Exactly, just keep plodding along winning games and not being mentioned too muchApparantly it was only a good day for Emirates Marketing Project, we didnt get mentioned...but, let it stay like that, keep the pressure off our youngsters and heap it on the other challengers
Only a manager as good as Poch (and it took him a season) can recover a team from the damage caused by Captain Bellend.Villa are going down. No way they are going to come back from 11 points deficit. Worst team in the league.
In my head I know a Chelsea win is good for us, but every fibre of my being is making me cheer United.United battering Chelsea...
Only a manager as good as Poch (and it took him a season) can recover a team from the damage caused by Captain Bellend.
United battering Chelsea...
If they'd had any kind of tactical and/or fitness work done over the summer then they would have had a decent chance. They've got a far better team than the likes of Bournemouth for example.No, they really are a bad football side, regardless of what Sherwood did or who he signed. They would have gone down in any of the previous 3 seasons if not for Benteke, who isn't there now.
In more ways than one!United battering Chelsea...