adding a caveat to mine, Waddle here as I have Jones as the only real option down the left, arguably the greatest winger of all time let alone the best Spurs one
If we end up with Bale on the left... then I would like to raise the suggestion that Tony Galvin should come into the voting. Although he played mainly on the left, Galvin could play on the right too.. as a kid he was one of my favourites, socks rolled down, no shin pads... hard as nails!
Agree. He could play on either flank but iirc was mainly used down the left in his early years before settling for the right later on. Who can forget his celebrated corner routine with Teddy Sheringham which for a time caught defences totally offguard and led to a few cracking goals from the corner of the box.Anderton is still criminally underrated because of the myth about his injuries.
He clocked up about 400 games for us and was our outstanding player of the 90s (IMO ahead of Teddy)
I got a call from a headhunter around 2003... Chap called Galvin. So I asked... And it was his cousin or somethingIf we end up with Bale on the left... then I would like to raise the suggestion that Tony Galvin should come into the voting. Although he played mainly on the left, Galvin could play on the right too.. as a kid he was one of my favourites, socks rolled down, no shin pads... hard as nails!
Of the players I've seen personally, my short-list would include... Waddle, Allen, Anderton, Davies, Lennon.
Here's a question for you though... what about Ossie Ardiles? I know he wasn't a winger / wing forward, but in my mind he generally tended to play as much on the right of midfield as he did in the centre. Or is that my memory playing tricks on me?
Blanchflower needs to be in this team. Full stop. Put him somewhere, in goal if needs be.
Should be Blanchflower with Mackay and Hoddle right side. Hoddle was better than Waddle.
If we have Greaves up top we could have Sheringham behind for height and goals and supply... So no wingers like Waddle and Bale but instead of that a narrow three of Hoddle Sheringham Gazza, behind Greaves = GOALS
This team is going to be a mess. Lots of square pegs in round holes. It will be a legend XI, not a best ever XI.
I've made a number of posts pointing out how the poll selection and order can influence the XI selected, but I think you are wrong about the team element. My guess is that the final XI selected will be quite functional. We can argue over whether Perryman should be at rght-back or if Hoddle should keep out Blanchflower and Modric, but these disagreements are not going to add up to a dysfunctional selection.
It would be a very functional unit, but it wouldn't be the best possible XI.
Problem is that's not always how people have been voting.This team is going to be a mess. Lots of square pegs in round holes. It will be a legend XI, not a best ever XI.