Re: Bad substitution two weeks in a row
The subs the last two weeks have bemused me too. But what has me completely worried is:
a) last season we tried (didn't always succeed but we tried) to play a possession game, an attractive fluid game. This season we are rigid, tactically inept, dull, defensive minded and too often long ball because we run out of ideas. Now I am fully aware that VDV, Modric and Parker were the three main players in that passing game and all are missing, but I do really hope that it's just a case of the players getting used to the system because we truly are playing a turgid brand of football right now.
b) the last two weeks we've started 4-5-1 and looked average. We switch to 4-4-2 and go 1-0 up. Then, despite us being at home, we switch back to 4-5-1 to play out the 1-0 win and end up drawing 1-1. That frustrates the fudge out of me.
c) AVB seems to think Livermore is a better option than Sandro. I find that very strange!
d) Friedel has been our MOTM the last two matches.....at home.....to average sides. That is VERY worrying! And he'll probably be dropped for the next league game too which would send out an awful signal to the players IMHO. But how can you sign Lloris and then have him on the bench? That would send out a bad signal to anyone wanting to join the club.
e) we don't have a single midfielder who can put their foot on the ball or who is comfortable receiving a pass under pressure. Last season Modric/VDV/Parker were all very good at receiving the ball under pressure, this season we only have Bale who can receive it under pressure and still produce a pass or keep possession.
AVB has a lot of work to do, but we still have the players at the club to make top six. My final thoughts are that I warned people last season that the previous three years have been a mini golden era. People were so focused on the negatives and misguidedly believing that we could (even should!) have done better that they utterly failed to appreciate what was being achieved. Two 4th places in three seasons is an AMAZING achievement for a club of our limited stature. Even if Redknapp had stayed it was highly unlikely that we'd have matched the last three seasons, this season because those last three seasons we were punching above our weight. It simply wasn't sustainable regardless of who is in charge.
Agreed on all counts.
The players coming on weren't wrong, it was the initial team selection and the decisions on who was replaced that were downright awful today. Defoe on his own up front was never going to be a good idea against West Brom and it was shockingly bad, but AVB at least had the vague reasoning behind it that Adebayor was short of match practice and fitness. No such excuse today. We spent 56 minutes hoofing high balls up to Defoe who never won any of them of course and of course, created very little, we looked miles better once he came on. Not starting Dembele was almost as stupid, the guy is fit and in form and was buzzing and raring to go. Instead we started with two holding midfielders at home to a team that will in all likeliness be battling relegation this season. Of course we created fudge all. I was also surprised to see Gallas too, I really thought Caulker would be given a chance but Gallas was very poor today.
Once Adebayor and Dembele were on the pitch we scored a goal and had a couple of other chances. But by not starting them we effectively wasted the entire first half which is a ludicrous thing to do. AVB did bring on the right players but he also brought off the wrong ones. Sandro wasn't having a particularly good game, but neither was Livermore, and they are both holding midfielders, they perform the same role, and Sandro is clearly better. So what the fudge was AVB thinking in choosing him to go off instead? For the second week running? The next decision to take off Sigurdsson was also a poor one, as he is now there to carry out the creative role that Van Der Vaart used to do behind the striker. Surely anybody can see that we will see the best of him with the ball at his feet playing off Adebayor, not chasing non-existent knock downs from Defoe or coming deep to get the ball from one of the holding midfielders. Instead, we took him off for Adebayor. That meant that we had no passing midfielders left on the pitch, and there was a horrible moment where we got a corner and nobody even stepped up to take it because clearly nobody left on the pitch had been practising them. Finally, right near the end of the game, when we were in the lead and finally on the front foot, AVB took off Defoe, a striker, who was working hard and was now finally in a formation that he might actually be able to do something useful in. And he took him off for Huddlestone, a defensive midfielder, to go on the back foot and allow Norwich to come at us, and of course, they scored.
I can accept a manager making a mistake here and there, or if the team drops points because a good player or a player we were forced to play through injuries has a bad game. But I cannot accept a manager not spotting basic basic things like the fact that hoofing high balls up to Defoe on his own up front is not going to achieve anything, even after he's already watched it go horribly wrong a week earlier. People used to say Harry was a bad tactician, but there's no way he would have had a team play Norwich at home with two holding midfielders hoofing high balls up to a midget striker when there were other players on the bench. What the fudge was AVB doing today?
Yeah yeah, give him time you say. I'm not writing off the possibility of him turning things around but I've been very unimpressed by what I've seen so far from AVB. If we'd won our opening three games in style then everyone would be jizzing themselves about how he's the next messiah, so it's only right that after dropping four points directly because of poor decisions he's made that I'd be very disappointed in him. 8 points from his last 9 games in English football, 17 from his last 15. That's practically relegation form over almost half a season. Please Andre, sort yourself out. I can't bear to consider the consequences of us having hired another brick manager who fudges things up for us.