But that doesn’t mean he isn’t any good
We don’t know in reality
Hence the reference to his past
I think you have to credit any guy who makes his way up
But you also have to factor in the next guy has to be as sure fire hit as we can get
It doesn't mean he isn't/won't be any good and that's not what I'm saying - it's just that the work he has done so far is no yardstick - it's a proper punt/gamble that he will be able to step up to a level and perform where the scope for improvement (comparatively) is so small