Yes he didn't hand over his mobile phone, and neither would have I. The texts from Tom Brady to these guys would have been on the locker room guys phones. At the point of Tom Brady spending the whole day being interviewed and answering every question (in the report, the report even states he was very cooperative also) during that interview and prior to it, the NFL was and still is going through a problem of unsolicitated leaks which seem to be finding there way to the New York media, would you want your intimate moments being looked at when such leaks were happening.
I must admit I did think you were also going to say that Brady said he never knew they guys when told the locker room guys names, well there is a reason, as Teddy Bruschi highlighted on ESPN highlight clip, none of the Patriots players know the locker guys by there actual names, they all have nicknames and he names one of the guys in the report as being known as chip.
So, my next point is why is this the point of blame, and if this is the point of blame 'for not cooperating' why is it then that during all these interviews going on Patriots kicker Stephen Gostowski was also called and also went through the same process as Brady.. he also did not hand over his mobile phone. So I ask, why is it bad and be damned if Brady doesn't hand over his mobile yet Gostowski isn't and was pretty much left out of the report. You cannot punish one, and not the other for the same crime. I think this will be a big part of the appeal. Although with some people there is over a hundred bones of contention that would get this report chucked out on the first day in a court.
The tuck rule has nothing to do with breaking or bending the rules, it was an legitimate ruling. I'd hazard a guess 90% of players would not of heard of it before that moment. You cannot castigate a team simply as they got lucky that a ruling existed. Its simply part of football.
Please comment on the Jets breaking the rules regarding spying with a camera yet Goddell saying oh well don't do it next time. Or why is it the Patriots get blasted but everyone else gets slaps on the wrist.
I find it all very odd.. and why I posted above likening the NFL and FIFA and how dodgy some of there actions are.