• Dear Guest, Please note that adult content is not permitted on this forum. We have had our Google ads disabled at times due to some posts that were found from some time ago. Please do not post adult content and if you see any already on the forum, please report the post so that we can deal with it. Adult content is allowed in the glory hole - you will have to request permission to access it. Thanks, scara

The best album of the 90's - Use Your Illusion (I and II) vs the Bends

Which album is better?


  • Total voters
    17
  • Poll closed .

milo

Jack L. Jones
In a tough heat to pick the winner, G'n'R are up against Radiohead in our fifth second round game. As with the rest of this round, I will add a poll once you've had a chance to chat about the albums.

Guns 'n' Roses - Use Your Illusion (I and II)

220px-GnR--UseYourIllusion1.jpg
220px-GunsnRosesUseYourIllusionII.jpg


Use Your Illusion I is the third studio album by the American rock band Guns N' Roses. It was the first of two albums released in conjunction with the Use Your Illusion Tour, the other being Use Your Illusion II. The album debuted at No. 2 on the Billboard charts, selling 685,000 copies in its first week, behind Use Your Illusion II's first week sales of 770,000.[1]Use Your Illusion I has sold 5,502,000 units in the U.S. as of 2010, according to Nielsen SoundScan.[2] Each of the Use Your Illusion albums have been certified 7× Platinum by the RIAA. It was nominated for a Grammy Award in 1992.[3]

Use Your Illusion II is the fourth studio album by the American rock band Guns N' Roses. It was one of two albums released in conjunction with the Use Your Illusion Tour, along with Use Your Illusion I. Bolstered by the lead single "You Could Be Mine," Use Your Illusion II was the slightly more popular of the two albums, selling 770,000 copies its first week and debuting at No. 1 on the U.S. charts, ahead of Use Your Illusion I's first week sales of 685,000.[7] As of 2010, Use Your Illusion II has sold 5,587,000 units in the U.S., according to Nielsen SoundScan.[8] Both albums have since been certified 7× Platinum by the RIAA.[9] It was also No. 1 on theUK Albums Chart for a single week. It is the last Guns N' Roses album to feature rhythm guitarist Izzy Stradlin. It also included the last Guns N' Roses song to feature drummer Steven Adler, who played on "Civil War."

Vs

Radiohead - The Bends

220px-Radiohead.bends.albumart.jpg


The Bends is the second studio album by the English alternative rock band Radiohead, released on 13 March 1995 by Parlophone Records internationally and by Capitol Records in the United States. The album was produced by John Leckie at EMI Studios inLondon, England and engineered by Nigel Godrich, who would go on to co-produce all future albums by the band. The Bends marked the beginning of a shift in aesthetics and themes for the band, with greater use of keyboards, and more abrasive guitar tracks while balancing with subtler ones. The introspective grunge-influenced style of their debut studio album Pablo Honey (1993) evolved into more multi-layered rock with cryptic lyrics and larger ideas, as the band and singer Thom Yorke reacted against the rigors of their near-constant world tours.

The Bends received greater critical acclaim than Pablo Honey, receiving an enthusiastic critical reaction, and it reached #4 on the UK Albums Chart.[3] However, it failed to build on the commercial success of the single "Creep" outside of the United Kingdom, and it peaked on the United States charts at #88.[4] Although it lacked the instant success of Radiohead's subsequent albums, The Bendsachieved triple platinum sales certifications in the UK and in Canada, as well as platinum sales certifications in the United States (by the Recording Industry Association of America) and in Europe. The album spawned five charting singles; My Iron Lung was first released as an EP in 1994 before the album was released, and later "High and Dry" was released with the album's opener "Planet Telex" as its B-side. "Fake Plastic Trees" was released as the second single from The Bends, followed by "Just". "Street Spirit (Fade Out)", the final single and last song on the album, became their first top 5 hit in the United Kingdom. In the years since its release, the album has frequently appeared in listener polls and critics' lists of the best albums of all time.
 
it's the best work of neither

there is a lot I love on UYI between the fluff (mostly on 1) though, and it gets my vote
 
Nothing better then a last minute winner.

I'm surprised by the result. I think that Use Your Illusion is a pretty poor album and certainly not a landmark album for the decade. The Bends marks the point where Radiohead start to stretch themselves but are still writing good pop songs.
 
I'm surprised by the result. I think that Use Your Illusion is a pretty poor album and certainly not a landmark album for the decade. The Bends marks the point where Radiohead start to stretch themselves but are still writing good pop songs.

One of the reasons i did not vote earlier is because i could not make up my mind which to choose ( as i like both choices), what made me go for GNR is that i have seen them live ( and really enjoyed them), Radiohead are one of the acts i have never been able to get to so i went on that.
 
it's the best work of neither

there is a lot I love on UYI between the fluff (mostly on 1) though, and it gets my vote
Having listened to both again in the car yesterday, I think The Bends is much closer to Radiohead's best than UYI is to GnR's.

The Bends marks the point where Radiohead start to stretch themselves but are still writing good pop songs.
You and I have the Radiohead quality vs time graph pointing in different directions, but I think they intersect at The Bends with it being near the top for both.

Listening to it again a couple of times lately reminded me how full of top songs it is - there's pretty much no filler at all. UYI has a few I'd skip every time
 
Having listened to both again in the car yesterday, I think The Bends is much closer to Radiohead's best than UYI is to GnR's.

You and I have the Radiohead quality vs time graph pointing in different directions, but I think they intersect at The Bends with it being near the top for both.

Listening to it again a couple of times lately reminded me how full of top songs it is - there's pretty much no filler at all. UYI has a few I'd skip every time

What we had here was Radiohead's Rubber Soul up against G'n'R's White Album.
 
No wonder the record industry is filthy rich.

A victory for ultra MoR rock.

Just to remind you all, the singles from this album were November Rain and Don't Cry - too soppy MoR rock ballads and a cover version of a James Bond theme by Wings....so that middle of the road it has a cats eye on the cover.

Guns and Roses produced one the best rock albums ever in '89 - then followed it with the equivalent of a Spa Day.
 
No wonder the record industry is filthy rich.

A victory for ultra MoR rock.

Just to remind you all, the singles from this album were November Rain and Don't Cry - too soppy MoR rock ballads and a cover version of a James Bond theme by Wings....so that middle of the road it has a cats eye on the cover.

Guns and Roses produced one the best rock albums ever in '89 - then followed it with the equivalent of a Spa Day.

The two most popular singles. Not unlike Metallica with Unforgiven and Nothing Else Matters.

They also released the singles You Could Be Mine, Yesterdays, Garden of Eden, The Garden, Dead Horse, Civil War, Estranged and my least favorite GNR track: Knockin on Heaven's Door. They really ought to stop playing that and Live And Let Die live.

They should probably have shown some restraint and saved the more obscure tracks for another stop gap album like Lies.
 
Back