Jurgen the German
Willie Hall
I agree with both of you.
It is ridiculous that ultimate success in a competition that some individuals don't have a real chance of winning is considered a major criteria for determining the best individual. The reality, however, is that it does. The problem is how can you not consider Pele's three world cups and Maradona's success a part of the equation.
Many people already consider Messi the best ever or put him on par with the best. A world cup win can only add to that. For many people the debate will be ended, although not for me.
It's unfair but that's how people judge the greats. The fact is Maradona won the World Cup with what most experts and fans would describe as an average team and won the league with Napoli who have nowhere near as much clout financially as Juve, the Milan clubs and the Rome clubs. That for me is more impressive than what Pele achieved in his career, he got injured during one of those World Cups but they still went on to win it without him.