My opinion hasn't been from what I've read but more just a hollow feeling whilst watching us play this season
I wouldn't say we play a high line like we did under AVB but our defense still gets cut through time and time again. The game against the Cypriots was a good example of that, time and time again they got through and we were quite fortunate to have only conceded one (although it was a humorous one...)
There we go! What do you mean we aren't even playing a pressing game? Of course we are, it's called trying to get the ball back. Unless we were waiting to regain possession by manner of a kick off or a goal kick there definitely has to be an element of pressing involved and we;ve won the ball in good positions and benefited from it ie the Arsenal goal but it's funny when it's spoken of like a brand new concept.
I wish I was as positive as you to have seen purposeful play but that just isn't my viewpoint of it, Bale was purposeful because he'd get the ball and do something with it.
I haven't been critical of the manager on here just until now but it's got to be said about how poor it's been, in no way am I saying Poch out or anything, I'm just concerned. In no way can I look at Pochettino's CV and be overwhelmed but there must be a reason we hired him and hopefully he'll be a massive success but I still see the complete lack of balls, concentration and attacking potency that we've seen for a while...
yeah a 'pressing game' in terms of what Southampton and Porto played isn't quite just trying to win the ball back, well not to my limited understanding is - it's an almost relentless drive to close down and harry your opponents high up the pitch - there's more to it im sure but it's much more than just challenging your opponents - perhaps someone more articulate on the subject could educate us a little... anyway on this particular facet of our play i think we've seen, as the 10 games have worn on the team play deeper and more prepared to soak up some pressure and even a bit of counter attacking play starting to creep in - no doubt buoyed by our effective play away to Arsenal. under AVB it was slower and more passing for passing sake and generally not knowing what to do with it - for me although we're still obviously we're nowhere near what he wants from us i at least see more drive to get forward and in to the opponents third, more chances being created and so forth. we still have a habit of going quiet for periods and what appears to be pointless passing - but id expect to see this lessen as everything settles.
For me the issue is players can underperform and still get in the team week after week regardless.
yeah a 'pressing game' in terms of what Southampton and Porto played isn't quite just trying to win the ball back, well not to my limited understanding is - it's an almost relentless drive to close down and harry your opponents high up the pitch - there's more to it im sure but it's much more than just challenging your opponents - perhaps someone more articulate on the subject could educate us a little... anyway on this particular facet of our play i think we've seen, as the 10 games have worn on the team play deeper and more prepared to soak up some pressure and even a bit of counter attacking play starting to creep in - no doubt buoyed by our effective play away to Arsenal. under AVB it was slower and more passing for passing sake and generally not knowing what to do with it - for me although we're still obviously we're nowhere near what he wants from us i at least see more drive to get forward and in to the opponents third, more chances being created and so forth. we still have a habit of going quiet for periods and what appears to be pointless passing - but id expect to see this lessen as everything settles.
Maybe it's a bit unnecessary to throw more negativity in to the equation at this point but I am just wondering exactly what Poch is trying to and how he means to go about it.
It looks very much similar to AVB's turgid attacking play and weak defense, mainly because it's pretty much the same players in the same system. Makes me laugh when I hear about our attacking pressing Poch style of play, what ****ing team does not "press" the ball and also attempt to attack. It's called getting the ball and scoring goals and that to me is a pretty basic concept that every team attempts to do.
Gentlemen we have a winner!:ross:
My understanding of the pressing games is that one of the key principles of it is that a very high percentage of goalscoring opportunites are created by a turnover in possession high up the pitch. By pressing from the front you are trying to force your opponents into mistakes that will create goalscoring chances.
Yes, when you win the ball you have 3 or 4 seconds to put together an incisive move, before the opposition recover and get set in defensive positions.
Where we go wrong is that 2 or 3 of our players take 2 seconds to control it, look left, look right, play a short pass that is not incisive. It is such a difference when a player already knows who is around him and knows what he plans to do and just does it first time, passing to a team mate who is already making the key run in on goal, ping ping ping goal.
Yes, when you win the ball you have 3 or 4 seconds to put together an incisive move, before the opposition recover and get set in defensive positions.
Where we go wrong is that 2 or 3 of our players take 2 seconds to control it, look left, look right, play a short pass that is not incisive. It is such a difference when a player already knows who is around him and knows what he plans to do and just does it first time, passing to a team mate who is already making the key run in on goal, ping ping ping goal.
our best line up is easily:
Kane
Eriksen - Lamela - Chadli
Stambouli - Dembele
Rose - Vert - Fazio - Walker
Lloris
Can't wait until Poch realises.
Wow, we have really regressed if that's what we have to look forward to. I think even this team from the recent past would give that one a good game
...................Friedel
Corluka..Dawson...King....BAE
Lennon Thudd Parker Kranjcar
....................VDV
..................Defoe
Yeah, no need for Bale or Modric either
our best line up is easily:
Kane
Eriksen - Lamela - Chadli
Stambouli - Dembele
Rose - Vert - Fazio - Walker
Lloris
Can't wait until Poch realises.
I agree other than Soldado for Kane..
I'm just saying that if the team you posted is our way forward then we have problems ahead. Nothing against you, just that I don't think that overall the players we have now are any better than who we had a few years ago. Its more an observation about our recruitment policywhats wrong with the team posted? - lol at old man friedel, one knee king, as mobile as an oil tanker hudd, circle-doodle-do Parker and Lennon in the team you think'd do well. :lol:
It's the Barca defensive system.
The player nearest the man with the ball goes to that man and the next two nearest close the space.
If the ball isn't recovered in 20 seconds (that may be wrong) you retreat to create a defensive line
It's incredibly simple but physically demanding and it takes phenomenal discipline
I get my 5 as side team doing it every game and we smash teams that are better by physically turning over the ball in their half and having ****s from reasonable distance. However in 5 a side you can be exposed due to less numbers
Our biggest problem is too many touches b certain players when a quick ball would work. Lamella at one point in the second half took 13 touches to gain about 8 yards and they won the goal kick
I was taught to let the ball do the work which is why I'm a lard **** but can still play well enough as I can pass well... Our players currently other than Mason are passing really bad,y and just not quick enough
I'm just saying that if the team you posted is our way forward then we have problems ahead. Nothing against you, just that I don't think that overall the players we have now are any better than who we had a few years ago. Its more an observation about our recruitment policy