You should have thrown those questions at Poch before he joined us. I think it’s a shame that not more young managers are given a chance at the bigger jobs - I don’t doubt that a Howe, or even a Dyche could do a job at one of the big boys with the resources at their disposal if given time to adapt (time is always the issue I guess)....
When Poch came in it was between he, LVG and Frank De Boer. I actually favoured FDB, though that was more a stylistic thing than thinking Poch wasnt good enough, it was a preference between two good choices.
And before he went to Utd, while I wanted FDB I thought it was obvious we should get LVG if we could simply because of his record.
I wont judge a manager to harshly on what they havent had the opportunity to do, providing they show the sort of tendencies I think will lead to success.
Howe? My big concern with him is Bournemouth. He has been there so long, struggled when he went to Burnley, then thrived again back at Bournemouth... I wonder if he is too embedded there to settle somewhere else in good time. And I think thats a valid worry.
Poch, before coming to us, had already shown that ability.
Im a big fan of Dyche. I really liked him at Watford and think he has done amazing things with Burnley. The question with him, for me, is that of style. With greater resources (and quality of player) can he really get a team attacking?
He might well be able to, but its the main doubt I have. Its most likely the constraints at Burnley lead to a rather pragmatic style (completely understandable) - but it does leave room for doubt.
As it is, over time they are becoming a more complete team, I suppose Id just like to be more certain Dyche has that in him.