John Moncur was there for a long time but that probably crossed over with the Championship. Lampard maybe? Lomas captained them for a while but I think he played a lot in the Championship with them too (may be wrong there). That probably discounts Carrick as well. Hislop and Di Canio must have racked up a fair few as well.
I'll go for Hislop and Lampard?
Ibrahim Afellay
Leroy Fer
Jozy Altidore
Wilfried Bony
Christian Eriksen
Erik Pieters
Bacuna
Marco Van Ginkel
Denis Law?