THFC6061
Paul Robinson
Sheringham?
No, not Teddy.
Sheringham?
Demba Ba?
Tony Cottee in his 2nd spell?
So the gaps are 1992-93 (were they in the PL?), 1996-2002, 2003-05 and 2009-10. That rules out Tevez. How about Zamora and Harewood?
Darren Fletcher (Manchester United 2007, 2008, 2009, 2011) and Darren Ferguson (Manchester United 1993) are both correct.
Two more to get...