I guess there were lots of opinions about his lack of self control and defensive lapses, and to be honest they were probably valid at the time. He has improved beyond expectation in most aspects of his game.
oh definitely, nothing wrong with not rating a player but it went far beyond that for Rose for quite a few posters, some of whom are very quick to call others out when talking down players they rate...
id like to think examples such as this would teach people to be a little more patient with young players but nothing ever changes they just move on to the next