Bad pundit world cup - Alan Smith v Glenn Hoddle

[Glenda's Legs]

Hoddle as a pundit I don't mind too much. As a co-commentator he's not good. Maybe because he has time to fill but he does have a tendency to spout drivel. And his voice/tone is not especially suited to commentary (although not on the Owen-scale).
But that's as far as I'll let myself go to say anything bad about him. (Except that he does seem too admiring of Cheatski sometimes).

Smith is a stand-out candidate among what should be a very strong short-list to win this whole contest. Awful. Adds no value. Let's his dislike of us shine through.

 

[milo]

The result was never in doubt. Smith goes through to be constantly wrong in the next round.

 

[Mikey10]

I prefer pundits who can stay balanced.

Even the like of Ian Wright and Martin Keown - clearly Arsenal fans, and clearly more supportive of Arsenal - will always praise other teams (including us) when its fair, as well as critisise Arsenal when its fair.

I respect that a lot, its at least honest.

I have a lot of time for Ian Wright as a pundit. He is balanced, honest and comes across as pretty down to earth. Pity he was a complete clam during his playing days, mind.

 

[StephenH]

I don't mind Smith
Noddles is so poor on BT, he is horrible! He always like sitting an interview for a manager job!

 

[the dza]

I've said it before and I'll say it again: Alan Smith, gooner qunt.

 

[parklane1]

Late to this but my vote would have gone to Smith as well, having said that Hoddle is the best player i have seen in a Spurs shirt but he is crap as a pundit.